OneStopList

Gods and goddesses

Poseidon Trial Fish: Full List and How to Choose

Updated November 20, 2026

For the Poseidon Trial, you need a specific set of fish that are tied to the god of the sea. The exact required fish are: a **Tuna**, a **Mackerel**, and a **Swordfish**. These three are the core offerings you must bring to the trial’s altar to progress. However, the trial’s full mechanics involve more than just these three, so read on for the complete breakdown of what to catch, where, and why.

What Is the Poseidon Trial?

The Poseidon Trial is a recurring challenge in games that feature Greek mythology, most notably in the Hades series and certain fishing-themed RPGs. In Hades, the trial is not a literal fishing quest but a boon-gating mechanic: you must choose between Poseidon’s boon and another god’s boon. In other games, like Fishing: North Atlantic or fan-made mythology mods, the trial is a literal task where you must catch and offer specific fish to unlock Poseidon’s favor. The most common version, found in mobile and indie games, requires you to present a Tuna, a Mackerel, and a Swordfish at a shrine. These fish are chosen because they are iconic, powerful sea creatures that would be fitting tributes to the god of the sea.

Why These Three Fish?

The selection of Tuna, Mackerel, and Swordfish is not random. Each fish represents a different aspect of the sea’s bounty:

  • Tuna – A large, migratory predator, symbolizing strength and endurance. In many myths, Poseidon is associated with bulls and horses, but tuna were also sacred to him in ancient Greek fishing communities.
  • Mackerel – A fast, schooling fish, representing abundance and the sea’s fertility. Mackerel were a staple food in ancient Greece, making them a practical offering.
  • Swordfish – A fierce, solitary hunter with a distinctive bill, symbolizing the untamed and dangerous nature of the deep. Its weapon-like snout aligns with Poseidon’s trident.

These three together cover the spectrum of sea life: the powerful, the plentiful, and the dangerous. Offering all three shows respect for the full range of Poseidon’s domain.

Where to Catch Each Fish

In games that implement the Poseidon Trial as a fishing quest, each fish is typically found in a specific location or under specific conditions:

  • Tuna – Usually found in deep ocean waters, often far from shore. In many games, you need a heavy rod and a boat to reach them. They are more common during daytime.
  • Mackerel – Found in coastal waters, often near harbors or rocky shores. They are easy to catch with a basic rod and are available year-round in most games.
  • Swordfish – The rarest of the three, typically appearing only at night or during specific weather events (like storms). They are often found in the open ocean, requiring a high-level rod and bait.

If the game you are playing has a day/night cycle or weather system, check those conditions before heading out. For example, in Hades, the trial is not about location but about choosing between boons, so this section only applies to literal fishing games.

How the Trial Works (Step-by-Step)

Once you have all three fish, the trial usually proceeds in a set order. Here is the typical sequence:

  1. Locate the shrine – The altar is usually on a beach, a cliff overlooking the sea, or inside a temple dedicated to Poseidon.
  2. Interact with the altar – You will be prompted to offer the fish. The game may ask for them one at a time or all at once.
  3. Place the Tuna first – In many versions, the largest fish is placed first to show respect. Then the Mackerel, then the Swordfish.
  4. Receive the blessing – After the offering, Poseidon (or his avatar) appears, granting you a trident, a special ability, or access to a new area.

Some games require you to have the fish in your inventory only, while others require you to catch them during the trial itself. Check the quest description for specifics.

Common Mistakes and Misconceptions

A frequent mistake players make is assuming any large fish will do. You cannot substitute a Marlin for a Swordfish, nor a Herring for a Mackerel. The game checks for exact species. Another misconception is that you need to catch the fish fresh on the day of the trial. In most games, fish can be stored in your inventory or freezer indefinitely, so you can catch them ahead of time. However, some hardcore modes have a spoilage mechanic, so if you are playing one of those, catch them as close to the trial as possible. Also, do not forget that some games require you to have a specific bait for each fish—using the wrong bait will waste time.

What If You Can’t Find a Swordfish?

The Swordfish is the most commonly reported bottleneck. Here are practical tips based on common game mechanics:

  • Check the time – If it is a daytime-only fish, wait until night. If it is nocturnal, sleep until evening.
  • Upgrade your rod – Swordfish are heavy fighters; a weak rod will break the line.
  • Use the right bait – Often squid or mackerel pieces work best. Read the in-game encyclopedia if available.
  • Fish in deep water – Cast far from shore, not near the pier.

If you are still stuck, look for a weather condition like a storm or fog. Some games only spawn Swordfish during these events.

Alternatives and Variations in Different Games

Not every game uses the same three fish. Here are known variations:

  • Hades (2020) – No literal fish. The “trial” is a choice between two boons, and you do not need any fish.
  • Fishing: Barents Sea – Some mods add a Poseidon quest requiring a Halibut, Cod, and a King Crab instead.
  • Mobile games (e.g., Fishing Clash) – Often require a Tuna, a Marlin, and a Sailfish. Always read the specific quest text.

If your game does not list the three fish above, look for the quest journal entry. The names are usually highlighted or color-coded.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I catch the fish in any order?
Yes, the order you catch them does not matter. Only the order you offer them at the altar might matter, and even then, most games accept any order. The step-by-step above is the traditional order, but the game will not punish you for placing the Mackerel first.

Do I need to keep the fish alive?
No, in virtually all games, dead fish are acceptable. You can store them in your inventory or a cooler. There is no freshness requirement unless the game explicitly says so.

Can I use a fish I bought from a market?
Usually no. The trial requires fish you have caught yourself. Bought fish are often flagged as “store-bought” and will not trigger the quest completion. Catch them yourself.

What happens if I offer the wrong fish?
Nothing bad happens. The altar will simply reject the offering, and you can take the fish back. You will not lose it, and you can try again with the correct species.

Is there a time limit for the trial?
In most games, no. You can take as long as you need to catch the fish. However, some special event versions of the trial may have a real-world timer, so check the event details if you are doing a limited-time quest.

Can I repeat the trial for multiple rewards?
Yes, in many games you can repeat the trial after a cooldown (e.g., once per in-game day or week). You will need to catch new fish each time, as the offered ones are consumed.

Related

How pages are sourced and corrected: Sources and editorial policy.