Apollo Bagels currently operates three locations in New York City: two in Manhattan (at 1961 Second Avenue in the Upper East Side and 41 West 14th Street in the West Village) and one in Brooklyn (at 2873 Coney Island Avenue in Sheepshead Bay). These are the only official Apollo Bagels stores as of this writing; the brand does not have locations in Queens, the Bronx, or Staten Island.
Background: A Neighborhood Bagel Shop That Grew
Apollo Bagels started as a single neighborhood bagel shop in Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn, a community with deep roots in New York’s Jewish and Eastern European food traditions. The owners, a Greek-American family, opened the first store decades ago, and the shop became known for its hand-rolled, kettle-boiled bagels and generous cream cheese spreads. Over time, the brand expanded into Manhattan, first to the Upper East Side and later to the West Village, while keeping its original Brooklyn store running. Unlike some chain bagel shops that use frozen dough, Apollo Bagels has historically made its bagels fresh on-site daily, which is a key part of its reputation among locals.
How to Find the Right Apollo Bagels for You
Each of the three locations has a slightly different character, so choosing one depends on what you need. The Upper East Side store at 1961 Second Avenue (between 101st and 102nd Streets) is a compact takeout spot with a few tables; it gets busy with commuters and nearby residents. The West Village store at 41 West 14th Street (near Sixth Avenue) is larger and has more seating, making it a good choice if you want to sit down with a coffee. The original Brooklyn store at 2873 Coney Island Avenue (near Avenue X) is the most traditional, with a full deli counter, a wide selection of spreads, and a loyal local following. If you’re looking for the full Apollo experience, the Brooklyn location is the one to visit.
What Makes Apollo Bagels Distinctive
Apollo Bagels is known for a few specific things that set it apart from other NYC bagel shops:
- Hand-rolled bagels: The dough is shaped by hand, not by machine, which gives the bagels a slightly irregular, rustic look and a chewier texture.
- Kettle-boiling: The bagels are boiled in a kettle of water (often with malt syrup) before baking, which creates the shiny, crisp crust and dense interior that defines a New York bagel.
- Wide variety of spreads: Beyond classic plain and vegetable cream cheese, Apollo offers flavors like lox spread, scallion, and even a spicy jalapeño option, plus a full menu of breakfast sandwiches and deli items.
- Freshness: Bagels are baked throughout the morning, so the best time to go is before noon, when they’re still warm from the oven.
Common Problems and How to Avoid Them
One frequent issue at Apollo Bagels is the wait. The Upper East Side and West Village locations can have long lines on weekend mornings, especially between 9 and 11 a.m. To avoid this, go early (before 8 a.m.) or later in the afternoon (after 2 p.m.), when the rush has died down. Another common complaint is that the bagels sell out quickly, particularly popular flavors like everything or sesame. If you have your heart set on a specific type, call ahead or visit before 10 a.m. Also, note that the stores are cashless; they accept credit and debit cards but not cash, which surprises some first-time visitors. Finally, if you’re ordering a sandwich, be specific about how you want it toasted and what toppings you want—the staff is efficient but busy, and they’ll make it exactly as you ask if you’re clear.
Comparing Apollo Bagels to Other NYC Bagel Spots
Apollo Bagels holds its own against more famous names like Russ & Daughters, Ess-a-Bagel, and H&H Bagels, but with a few differences. Russ & Daughters (on the Lower East Side) is a historic appetizing store known for its lox and smoked fish, not primarily for bagels; it’s more expensive and more of a sit-down experience. Ess-a-Bagel (with locations in Midtown and Brooklyn) makes a larger, fluffier bagel and is often cited as a favorite for its variety of flavors. H&H Bagels (which closed its original Upper West Side store but has a location on the Upper East Side) is famous for its classic, dense style. Apollo’s bagels are closer to the traditional New York style—smaller, denser, and chewier than Ess-a-Bagel’s—and they’re generally cheaper than Russ & Daughters. If you want a no-frills, authentic neighborhood bagel at a reasonable price, Apollo is a solid choice.
Costs and Ordering Tips
Prices at Apollo Bagels are typical for NYC: a plain bagel costs around $1.50, a bagel with cream cheese is about $3.50, and a breakfast sandwich (egg and cheese, for example) runs $5–$7, depending on additions like bacon or sausage. Smoked salmon (lox) sandwiches are pricier, usually $12–$15. To save money, order a bagel with a tub of cream cheese to go, rather than a toasted sandwich. If you’re ordering for a group, call ahead to place a bulk order—the stores can prepare dozens of bagels with spreads for events, and it’s often cheaper per bagel than ordering individually. Also, ask about the day-old bagel discount; some locations sell leftover bagels at a reduced price in the afternoon, which is a good deal if you’re not picky about freshness.
Safety and Quality Notes
Apollo Bagels follows standard food safety practices common to all NYC food service establishments. The stores are inspected by the NYC Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, and their letter grades are posted at each location (you can check the current grade online). If you have a food allergy, be aware that the shops handle wheat, sesame, eggs, dairy, and fish (lox) in the same workspace, so cross-contamination is possible. For anyone with a gluten sensitivity, Apollo does not offer gluten-free bagels, so that’s a limitation. As with any fresh-baked product, bagels are best eaten the same day; if you buy extras, store them in a paper bag at room temperature for up to two days, or freeze them in a sealed plastic bag for up to three months. To reheat a frozen bagel, slice it first, then toast it directly from the freezer—do not microwave it, as that will make it rubbery.
Alternatives If You Can’t Make It to Apollo
If you’re not near an Apollo Bagels location, there are other respected bagel shops in NYC that offer a similar experience. In Manhattan, you could try Absolute Bagels on the Upper West Side (known for its sesame bagels), Tal Bagels on the Upper East Side, or Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company in Chelsea. In Brooklyn, Shelsky’s of Brooklyn in Cobble Hill is a good alternative, and Bagel Hole in Park Slope is famous for its small, dense, old-style bagels. These shops all make fresh, kettle-boiled bagels, though each has its own style. If you’re willing to travel, a bagel crawl across the city can be a fun way to compare.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Apollo Bagels deliver? Yes, all locations offer delivery through third-party apps like Uber Eats, DoorDash, and Grubhub. However, delivery fees and wait times can be high during peak hours, and the bagels may not arrive as fresh as they are in-store. For the best experience, order pickup directly from the store.
Are Apollo Bagels open on weekends? Yes, all three locations are open seven days a week, typically from early morning (around 6:00 a.m.) to early afternoon (around 3:00 p.m.) on weekdays, and slightly later on weekends. Hours can vary by location, so check the specific store’s listing before you go.
Do Apollo Bagels have vegan options? Yes, they offer vegan cream cheese (usually a tofu-based spread) and a variety of vegetable toppings. The bagels themselves are vegan (they don’t contain eggs or dairy), but note that some flavors, like egg bagels or cheese bagels, are not vegan. Ask the staff for the vegan selection.
Can I order a bagel with lox and cream cheese? Absolutely. The classic lox sandwich comes with cream cheese, capers, red onion, tomato, and lox (smoked salmon). It’s a popular item, and you can customize it by adding cucumber or avocado for an extra charge.
Is there seating at Apollo Bagels? The Upper East Side location has a few stools, the West Village location has a small dining area, and the Brooklyn location has a larger seating area with tables and a deli counter. None of the locations are full-service restaurants; you order at the counter and find a seat yourself.
Do Apollo Bagels offer catering or bulk orders? Yes, they do. You can call any location to place a bulk order for bagels, spreads, and sandwiches for events. It’s best to give at least 24 hours’ notice for large orders, especially on weekends.
Related
- Cities by GDP: Ranking & How It Works
- Fruits Offering Bouquets in Bukit Batok
- Calypso Island Tram: Route, Cost, and How It Works
How pages are sourced and corrected: Sources and editorial policy.