OneStopList

Gods and goddesses

Apollo Bagels NYC: A Guide to the Upper West Side Spot

Updated November 21, 2026

Apollo Bagels is a well-known bagel shop located on the Upper West Side of Manhattan, at 2432 Broadway (between 89th and 90th Streets). It has been serving the neighborhood for decades, earning a loyal following for its hand-rolled, boiled, and baked bagels, as well as its generous spreads and sandwiches. While it may not have the same international fame as some older Lower East Side institutions, Apollo is a genuine local staple that many New Yorkers consider among the city’s best.

Background and History

Apollo Bagels has operated at its Broadway location for over 30 years, though the exact founding year is not widely publicized. The shop is a classic New York bagel store: a narrow storefront with a counter, a display case of cream cheeses and salads, and a visible kitchen where bagels are made fresh throughout the day. Unlike some newer “artisanal” shops, Apollo follows the traditional process: dough is shaped by hand, boiled briefly in water (often with barley malt), then baked on stone or metal peels. This method produces the dense, chewy interior and shiny, slightly crisp crust that defines a New York bagel.

The Upper West Side has a long history of Jewish delis and bakeries, and Apollo sits in that lineage. While it is not a kosher-certified establishment, it offers many traditional options like lox, whitefish, and kasha knishes. The shop’s longevity in a competitive neighborhood—where rent and real estate pressures have closed many smaller businesses—is a testament to its consistent quality and community support.

What Makes Apollo’s Bagels Distinctive

Apollo’s bagels are boiled and baked daily, and they are noticeably larger and softer than some of the “crusty” style popular in Brooklyn. The interior is airy but still chewy, with a slight pull when torn. The exterior is golden and slightly blistered in places, a sign of proper boiling and baking. The shop offers a standard range of flavors:

  • Plain, sesame, poppy, everything, and salt
  • Cinnamon raisin, blueberry, and chocolate chip
  • Pumpernickel, rye, and whole wheat
  • Garlic, onion, and “everything” variations

One notable feature is the sheer size of the bagels—they are among the largest in the city, which makes them a filling meal on their own. The cream cheese spreads are made in-house and include classic scallion, vegetable, and lox spread, as well as seasonal options. The store also sells bagel chips, rugelach, and other baked goods, but the bagels are the main draw.

How to Order and What to Get

Ordering at Apollo is straightforward: you wait in line (which can be long on weekend mornings), then tell the counter staff what you want. They will ask if you want it toasted and whether you want it “schmeared” (with cream cheese) or as a sandwich. A few tips for first-timers:

  • If you want a classic, order an “everything with scallion cream cheese” – it’s the most popular.
  • For a full breakfast, try the “BEC” (bacon, egg, and cheese) on a roll or bagel – a New York staple.
  • For a lighter option, the “lox and bagel” (with tomato, onion, and capers) is a generous serving.
  • Ask for it “not toasted” if you want the traditional soft texture; toasting is common for sandwiches but not necessary for fresh bagels.

Apollo also sells bagels by the dozen, which is common for takeaway. They will slice them for free if you ask. The shop is cash-friendly but also accepts cards, though there may be a small minimum.

Common Questions and Misconceptions

One misconception is that Apollo Bagels is the same as “Apollo” on the Lower East Side or other boroughs – it is not. There is a separate “Apollo” brand in some locations, but the Upper West Side shop is independent. Another common question is whether the bagels are boiled in the same water as other shops – the answer is yes, but the exact recipe (including malt content and boiling time) is proprietary. Some visitors expect a “crispy” bagel like those from Montreal; Apollo’s are softer and larger, which is typical of New York style.

Another frequent question: “Is Apollo open 24 hours?” No, it is not. Hours vary, but typically it opens early (around 6:00 AM) and closes in the evening (around 7:00 PM or later on weekends). It’s best to check current hours online before visiting.

How Apollo Compares to Other NYC Bagel Shops

New York City has hundreds of bagel shops, and Apollo holds its own but has a distinct profile. Compared to the famous Ess-a-Bagel (Midtown) or H&H Bagels (which closed its original location but has a new one on the Upper West Side), Apollo’s bagels are slightly less dense and have a softer crust. Compared to Russ & Daughters (Lower East Side), Apollo is more of a neighborhood shop, less touristy, and generally cheaper. Absolute Bagels (also on the Upper West Side, on 107th Street) is often cited as a rival; many locals debate which is better. Apollo tends to have a larger selection of spreads and sandwiches, while Absolute is praised for its fluffy texture. In blind tastings, Apollo often ranks in the top tier for its balance of chew and flavor.

Cost and Value

Prices at Apollo are moderate for Manhattan. A plain bagel costs around $1.50–$2.00, and a bagel with cream cheese is around $3.50–$4.50. Sandwiches range from $6 to $12 depending on fillings. A dozen bagels is usually around $15–$20. These prices are comparable to other independent shops and slightly lower than tourist-heavy spots. The portions are generous, so most customers find the value good.

Practical Information and Tips

Apollo Bagels is located at 2432 Broadway, easily accessible via the 1 train (86th Street) or the 2/3 (96th Street). There is no seating inside – it’s strictly takeout, though there are a few stools by the window. The line moves quickly, but if you’re in a rush, you can call ahead and place an order for pickup. The shop is busiest on Sunday mornings, so go early (before 9 AM) or later in the afternoon (after 2 PM) to avoid the rush. They also offer delivery via third-party apps, though the bagels travel well.

One safety note: bagels are a high-carbohydrate food and are not suitable for gluten-free diets unless specified. Apollo does not offer gluten-free bagels. Also, if you’re buying a dozen to take home, store them in a paper bag at room temperature for up to two days, or freeze them in a sealed plastic bag for up to three months. To reheat, slice and toast or microwave for 20 seconds.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Apollo Bagels kosher? No, Apollo Bagels is not kosher-certified. It serves meat and dairy items, and while it follows some traditional practices, it does not hold a kosher certification. If you keep kosher, you may want to choose a certified shop.

Does Apollo Bagels deliver? Yes, Apollo offers delivery through services like Uber Eats, DoorDash, and Seamless. However, the bagels are best eaten fresh, so pickup is recommended if you live nearby.

What are Apollo Bagels’ hours? Hours vary, but generally the shop opens at 6:00 AM and closes around 7:00 PM on weekdays, and may close later on weekends. It’s best to call ahead or check online, as hours can change on holidays.

Can I order a bagel with lox and cream cheese? Yes, that’s a classic order. They serve lox (cured salmon) with cream cheese, tomato, onion, and capers. You can also get nova or sable, but lox is the standard.

Are there vegetarian or vegan options? Apollo has several vegetarian options, such as veggie cream cheese, avocado, and egg-and-cheese sandwiches. Vegan options are limited because most spreads contain dairy, but you can order a plain bagel with hummus or avocado if available.

Is Apollo Bagels the same as the Apollo Theater? No, the Apollo Theater is a famous music venue in Harlem, and it is not affiliated with Apollo Bagels. The name is coincidental.

Related

How pages are sourced and corrected: Sources and editorial policy.