The Sirens in Homer’s Odyssey are not said to live on an island with a specific name; Homer simply calls it their “meadow” or “shore,” and later tradition places them on the Sirenum scopuli, three rocky islets near the southern Italian coast. In Book 12, Circe warns Odysseus that his ship will pass the Sirens’ “flowery meadow” on the way back from the Underworld, and she gives him precise instructions to survive their song.
What Homer Actually Writes
In the Odyssey, Book 12, Circe describes the Sirens as creatures who sit in a meadow piled with the bones of men who have listened and wasted away. She tells Odysseus to stop the ears of his crew with beeswax and to have himself bound to the mast if he wants to hear the song. Homer gives no name for the island and no geographical coordinates; he only says the ship must pass between the Sirens and the wandering rocks (Planctae), which are often identified with the Clashing Rocks from the Argonautica. The Sirens’ own words in the poem—”come here, renowned Odysseus, great glory of the Achaeans”—are among the few direct quotes of a monster’s voice in Homer.
Ancient Geography and the Sirenum Scopuli
Later Greek and Roman writers tried to locate the Sirens in the real world. The most common identification is with the Sirenum scopuli (Siren Rocks), a group of small islands off the Sorrentine Peninsula in the Tyrrhenian Sea, near the modern town of Positano. The Roman poet Virgil, in the Aeneid, places the Sirens’ rocks near Cape Misenum, and the first-century geographer Strabo mentions them in his Geography. Another tradition, reported by the mythographer Apollodorus, says the Sirens were on the island of Anthemoessa, which means “flowery”—a direct echo of Homer’s “flowery meadow.” Some later commentators put them off Sicily, near Cape Pelorus, or even on the island of Capri, but none of these sites is confirmed by archaeology or by a single ancient text that gives exact coordinates.
Who the Sirens Were
The Sirens’ parentage varies by source. Homer does not name them or give their number. Hesiod, in the Catalogues of Women (a fragmentary work), says they were daughters of the river god Achelous and the Muse Terpsichore. Apollodorus names their mother as the Muse Melpomene. The most common count is three—generally called Peisinoe, Aglaope, and Thelxiepeia—but some vase paintings show two, and later writers sometimes list four. Their appearance also shifts: in Homer they are bird-women, and Greek art from the archaic period shows them with the bodies of birds and heads of women. By the Middle Ages, they had become fish-tailed mermaids, a change that stuck in popular imagination despite the ancient evidence.
Why Odysseus Survived
Circe’s advice is the key to the episode. She tells Odysseus to fill his crew’s ears with beeswax and to have them tie him to the mast with ropes, leaving his hands free only to gesture for more slack if he struggles. He follows the plan exactly: the crew rows past, Odysseus strains against the ropes, and the Sirens’ song ends as the ship moves out of earshot. The episode is often read as a parable about self-control and the limits of human curiosity. Unlike other heroes who die or go mad when they hear the Sirens, Odysseus hears them and lives because he has pre-committed to a constraint he cannot undo.
The Sirens’ Fate After Odysseus
Several later sources say the Sirens died after failing to lure Odysseus. The most common version, found in the Bibliotheca of Pseudo-Apollodorus, claims that an oracle said they would die when a ship passed them unharmed, and so they threw themselves into the sea after Odysseus escaped. Another tradition, from the Hellenistic poet Lycophron, says they were killed by the Argonauts when Orpheus outsang them, which would place their death before the Odyssey in chronological order. Neither story is in Homer, and the two accounts contradict each other, so the Sirens’ ultimate fate is genuinely uncertain in the mythic record.
Modern Misconceptions
A common misconception is that the Sirens were mermaids in Homer’s time. In fact, the earliest Greek art and literature consistently depict them as bird-women. The mermaid image comes from later European folklore and from the Latin translation of the Odyssey that conflated Sirens with sea nymphs. Another misconception is that the Sirens were on an island called “Siren Island” in the poem itself; no such name appears in any ancient text. The phrase “Siren Island” is a modern invention, used by travel guides and tourism websites for the Li Galli islands off Positano, which are sometimes called the Siren Islands in English but have no classical name.
Frequently Asked Questions
Did Odysseus actually hear the Sirens’ song?
Yes, in Homer’s account he heard it while tied to the mast. He asked his crew to release him, but they tightened the ropes instead, following his earlier orders. The song itself is quoted in the poem, so the audience hears it too.
Where is the Siren island in the Odyssey?
Homer does not name it. He only says it is a flowery meadow near the wandering rocks. Later writers placed it at the Sirenum scopuli off the Italian coast, but that identification is not in the poem.
Why did the Sirens sing?
The poem implies they sang to lure sailors to their death, and the meadow is full of rotting bodies. Their song promises knowledge—”we know all that happens on the fruitful earth”—which is why Odysseus wants to hear it despite the danger.
Are Sirens the same as mermaids?
No. In Greek myth they are bird-women. The mermaid form comes from later European legends and is not found in Homer or Hesiod.
What happened to the Sirens after Odysseus left?
Later sources say they died, either by throwing themselves into the sea or by being killed by Orpheus and the Argonauts. Homer does not say, and the two later versions contradict each other.
Related
- Hades in Greek Mythology: God, Realm, and Myths
- Hades Official Guide: Myths, Powers, and Worship
- Poseidon’s Origins: Myth, Cult, and Name
How pages are sourced and corrected: Sources and editorial policy.