OneStopList

Gods and goddesses

Italicize Poem Titles? Formatting Rules Explained

Updated November 18, 2026

No, the title of a poem should not be italicized in most cases; instead, it should be placed in quotation marks. This is the standard rule in MLA, APA, and Chicago style for poems published within a larger collection or anthology. However, if the poem is a standalone book-length work (like an epic), then its title is italicized.

Why Formatting Rules Exist

Formatting conventions for titles are not arbitrary—they signal to the reader what kind of work is being referenced. In the Western publishing tradition, italics indicate a self-contained, larger work (e.g., a novel, a film, an album), while quotation marks indicate a smaller piece contained within a larger work (e.g., a chapter, a song, an article). A poem, when it appears in a collection or magazine, is considered a component of that larger whole, so its title is set off with quotation marks. This system helps readers quickly distinguish between a full book and a single piece inside it.

The Standard Rule: Quotation Marks for Most Poems

For the vast majority of poems you will cite—whether in an essay, a blog post, or a bibliography—use double quotation marks around the title. This applies to:

  • Poems in anthologies (e.g., “The Road Not Taken” in a collection of Frost’s works)
  • Poems published in literary magazines or journals
  • Poems encountered online (unless the site itself uses a different style)
  • Song lyrics (which are poems set to music) in most contexts

For example, if you are writing about Shakespeare’s sonnet, you would write: “Sonnet 18” (or “Shall I compare thee to a summer’s day?” if using the first line as the title). In a works-cited entry, the poem’s title appears in quotation marks, followed by the title of the collection in italics.

When to Italicize a Poem Title

There is one major exception: if the poem is published as a standalone book, its title is italicized. This typically applies to long, epic poems that are their own volume. Examples include:

  • The Iliad and The Odyssey (Homer)
  • The Divine Comedy (Dante)
  • Paradise Lost (Milton)
  • The Waste Land (T.S. Eliot) – though often in collections, it is sometimes published as a chapbook

Also, if you are referring to the poem as a whole work in a context where italics are used for emphasis (e.g., a book title in a sentence), the same rule applies. But in standard citation, the rule is: if it is a book, italicize; if it is a part of a book, use quotes.

How to Choose: A Simple Decision Tree

  1. Ask: Is the poem published as a standalone book? If yes, italicize.
  2. If no (it appears in a collection, magazine, or website), place it in quotation marks.
  3. If you are unsure, check the citation style guide you are using (MLA, APA, Chicago) or look at how the publisher presents the title in the original source.

Common Problems and Misconceptions

A frequent mistake is italicizing all poem titles because they are “art” or because the poem is famous. But fame does not change the rule—even “The Raven” by Poe is in quotes when cited in an anthology. Another misconception is that you should underline a poem title when handwriting an essay; underlining is a holdover from typewriter days and is now considered equivalent to italics, so the same rule applies: underline only if the poem is a book-length work. Also, some style guides (like APA) have slight variations for citing poems in text vs. in the reference list, but the quotation mark rule for short poems remains consistent.

Comparison with Other Formats

Understanding how poems compare to other media can help cement the rule:

  • Short story – quotes (e.g., “The Lottery”)
  • Novel – italics (e.g., 1984)
  • Song – quotes (e.g., “Imagine”)
  • Album – italics (e.g., Abbey Road)
  • Article – quotes (e.g., “Why We Sleep”)
  • Magazine/Journal – italics (e.g., Time)

Poems align with the “short work” category, not the “long work” category. If you think of a poem as a song and a collection as an album, the pattern becomes intuitive.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I italicize a poem title in an essay?

No, unless the poem is a book-length work. For a typical poem in an anthology, use quotation marks. For example, in an essay about Frost, you would write “Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening” with quotes.

What about a poem posted on a website like Poetry Foundation?

If you are citing a poem from a website, the poem title goes in quotation marks, and the website name is italicized (if it is the container). In MLA, the website is the container, so you italicize the site name, not the poem.

How do I cite a poem in MLA format?

In MLA, the format is: Author’s Last Name, First Name. “Title of Poem.” Title of Collection, Publisher, Year, Page numbers. The poem title is in quotes, the collection title is in italics.

Is it different in APA style?

APA uses quotation marks for poem titles in text, but in the reference list, the poem title is in plain text (no quotes or italics) if it appears within a larger work. The collection title is italicized. For a standalone book poem, the title is italicized.

What if the poem has no title and I use the first line?

If a poem is untitled, use the first line as the title, in quotation marks. For example, “Whose woods these are I think I know” is used as the title for Frost’s poem. The same formatting rules apply.

Should I italicize a poem title in a tweet or social media post?

In informal contexts, you can use italics or quotes as you wish, but to be consistent with standard English, use quotes. On platforms that don’t support italics, you might use asterisks or just quotes, but the rule remains the same for formal writing.

Practical Tips for Writers

When in doubt, look at how the original publisher presents the poem title. If the title appears in quotes on the cover of a collection, use quotes. If the poem is a standalone volume, the cover will show the title in large letters without quotes, and you should italicize it. Also, remember that consistency is key—choose a style guide and stick to it throughout your document. Most word processors have an autocorrect feature that will format quotes and italics, but they won’t know the rule, so you must apply it manually.

Related

How pages are sourced and corrected: Sources and editorial policy.