OneStopList

Gods and goddesses

Hercules Pizza North Smithfield RI: Menu & Info

Updated November 21, 2026

Hercules Pizza is a long-standing, family-run pizzeria located in North Smithfield, Rhode Island, known for its thick, square-cut Sicilian-style pizza and hearty grinders. It has operated for decades at 635 Providence Pike (Route 146), serving a loyal local customer base that often cites its generous portions and old-school New England Italian-American cooking style.

Background and Reputation

Hercules Pizza has been a fixture in North Smithfield since the 1970s, though the exact founding year varies in local accounts. The restaurant is named not for the mythological hero but as a nod to the substantial size of its food—especially the signature thick-crust pizza that is cut into large, filling squares. It occupies a modest, unassuming building along Route 146, a busy commercial corridor that connects northern Rhode Island to Massachusetts. Regulars describe it as a classic “neighborhood joint” where the menu has changed little over the years and where the focus stays on volume and consistency rather than trendiness.

Signature Pizza Style

The defining item at Hercules is its Sicilian-style pizza: a thick, airy dough baked in rectangular trays, topped with a sweet-tangy tomato sauce and a generous layer of mozzarella. Unlike a New York-style thin slice, this pizza is dense and bready, often requiring two hands to hold. It is typically ordered by the square or by the full tray, and many locals prefer it reheated at home because the crust crisps up nicely. The cheese blend is standard mozzarella, but the sauce is what sets it apart—slightly sweeter than most, a trait common in older Rhode Island pizza shops. Pepperoni, sausage, and vegetable toppings are available, but the plain cheese square remains the most popular order.

Full Menu Beyond Pizza

While pizza is the headline, Hercules offers a full Italian-American menu that includes:

  • Grinders (subs) with hot or cold fillings—meatball, sausage, chicken parmesan, and steak and cheese are staples.
  • Baked pasta dishes such as lasagna, baked ziti, and stuffed shells, all served with garlic bread.
  • Calzones and stuffed pizzas, which use the same thick dough.
  • Chicken wings, fried appetizers like mozzarella sticks and onion rings, and a small selection of salads.
  • Desserts such as cannoli and tiramisu, though availability varies by day.

Portions are notably large—a single grinder can easily feed two people, and a small tray of pizza is often enough for a family of four. The restaurant also offers catering trays for parties and events, which is a common reason local offices and sports teams place orders.

How to Order and Pickup

Hercules operates primarily as a takeout and delivery spot, with a few small tables for dine-in service. The most reliable way to order is by phone, as the restaurant does not maintain a robust online ordering system on its own website—though third-party delivery apps like DoorDash and Grubhub have listed it in recent years. For pickup, customers typically call ahead, especially on Friday and Saturday evenings when wait times can reach 45 minutes to an hour. Payment is accepted in cash and credit cards, and the staff is known for being efficient but not chatty during busy rushes. If you plan to order a full tray of Sicilian pizza, it is wise to call at least 30 minutes in advance, as the thick crust requires longer bake time than thin-crust pies.

Common Questions and Misconceptions

A frequent misconception is that Hercules Pizza is affiliated with the Hercules brand of frozen food or with a chain of the same name elsewhere—it is not; it is an independent, single-location business. Another common question is whether the restaurant is Greek-owned (which would explain the thick crust and sweet sauce, a style common in Greek-American pizzerias). Local lore and employee accounts indicate the ownership is Italian-American, but the style does overlap with the “Greek pizza” tradition found throughout New England. Also, some visitors expect a sit-down restaurant with table service, but the reality is a counter-service, order-at-the-window setup with minimal seating. Finally, the name “Hercules” leads some to expect oversized, novelty portions—while the food is generous, it is not absurdly large; it is simply a filling, standard-size portion by Rhode Island standards.

Comparisons to Other Local Pizzerias

North Smithfield and the surrounding Woonsocket area have several pizza options, and Hercules stands out for its specific style. Compared to the thin, crispy crust at places like Wright’s Farm (a popular family-style restaurant in nearby Burrillville), Hercules is denser and more bread-like. Versus the New York-style slices at many Woonsocket shops, Hercules offers a heartier, more filling square. The closest comparison is to other Sicilian-style spots in northern Rhode Island, such as the now-closed Twin’s Pizza in Woonsocket or the still-operating Casa Roma in Smithfield—but locals often say Hercules has the most consistent sauce and the largest cheese coverage per square. For those who prefer gluten-free or cauliflower crusts, Hercules does not offer them, which sets it apart from newer, health-focused pizzerias in the area.

Cost and Value

Pricing at Hercules is moderate for the region. As of recent years, a single square slice costs around $3–$4, a half tray (roughly 12–16 squares) runs $15–$20, and a full tray is approximately $25–$35 depending on toppings. Grinders are priced between $8 and $12, and baked pasta dishes are in the $10–$14 range. These prices are slightly below the average for takeout pizza in Rhode Island, which makes the restaurant a strong value given the portion sizes. Cash orders sometimes receive a small discount, though this is not advertised. Delivery fees vary by distance, and the restaurant does not charge a surcharge for credit cards, unlike some smaller shops.

Safety and Food Handling

Because Hercules is a takeout-heavy operation, food safety practices are important to note. The Rhode Island Department of Health inspects the facility regularly, and the restaurant has maintained a generally clean record, with no major violations reported in public records. For customers, the key safety point is reheating: Sicilian pizza should be reheated to an internal temperature of at least 165°F (74°C) to ensure any bacteria are killed, especially if the pizza has been left out for more than two hours. The restaurant’s own reheating advice, often given over the phone, is to use an oven at 350°F for 10–12 minutes rather than a microwave, which makes the crust soggy. Perishable items like grinders with mayonnaise or pasta salads should be refrigerated within two hours of pickup and consumed within three to four days. The restaurant does not publish allergen information, so customers with severe allergies to wheat, dairy, or soy should ask about specific ingredients when ordering, as cross-contamination is possible in a shared kitchen.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are Hercules Pizza’s hours? The restaurant is typically open from 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. Monday through Thursday, 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. Friday and Saturday, and 12 p.m. to 8 p.m. on Sunday, but these hours can shift on holidays, so calling ahead is recommended.

Does Hercules Pizza deliver? Yes, they offer local delivery within a few miles of the restaurant, usually for orders over $10, with a small delivery fee. Third-party apps also handle delivery, but the restaurant’s own drivers may be faster during peak times.

Is the pizza really “Sicilian” style? Yes, in the American sense of the term—a thick, rectangular crust with a soft interior and crisp bottom. It is not the same as the thin, cracker-like Sicilian pizza found in Palermo, but it matches the style common in New England pizzerias.

Can I order a gluten-free crust? No, Hercules does not offer gluten-free options as of the latest available menu. All pizzas and grinders are made with standard wheat flour.

Is there seating inside? There are a few small tables and counter stools, but the space is primarily designed for takeout. Dine-in is available but limited, and you order at the counter rather than with a server.

Does Hercules Pizza have a website or online menu? The restaurant has a basic website with a phone number and directions, but it does not list full prices online. The most accurate menu is the printed one handed out at the counter, and prices are best confirmed by calling.

Related

How pages are sourced and corrected: Sources and editorial policy.