OneStopList

Gods and goddesses

Hercules Candy Company: History and Sweets

Updated November 21, 2026

The Hercules Candy Company is a family-owned confectionery manufacturer based in Syracuse, New York, known for its old-fashioned hard candies, chocolates, and seasonal treats since the early 20th century. The company was founded in 1920 by the Mastrodonato family, Italian immigrants who began making candy in a small shop and built a regional brand that still operates today.

Origins and Family History

Hercules Candy Company started in 1920 when Frank Mastrodonato, an immigrant from Italy, opened a small candy shop in Syracuse. The name “Hercules” was chosen to evoke strength and quality, a common marketing tactic of the era. The family business passed through generations, with descendants continuing to run the operation. Unlike many regional candy makers that were bought out by large corporations, Hercules remained independent, which helped preserve its traditional recipes and production methods.

The company originally made a wide range of penny candies and hard sweets, which were popular during the Great Depression and World War II due to their low cost. Over time, the product line expanded to include chocolate-covered items, fudge, and seasonal specialties. The factory has remained in Syracuse, and visitors can still buy directly from the retail store attached to the production facility.

Signature Products and Recipes

Hercules is best known for its hard candies, particularly the “Hercules Mix,” a bag of assorted fruit-flavored drops. The company also produces:

  • Butterscotch disks and peppermint rounds
  • Chocolate-covered cherries and creams
  • Seasonal items like candy corn, jelly beans, and holiday-shaped chocolates
  • Bulk candy sold by weight, popular at weddings and parties

The recipes rely on traditional methods: sugar, corn syrup, flavor oils, and food coloring are cooked in copper kettles, then poured onto cooling slabs and cut or stamped by hand. This process yields a denser, harder candy than mass-produced varieties, which many customers say has a more intense flavor. The chocolate used is a standard coating, not single-origin, but the company’s focus is on consistency and nostalgia rather than gourmet trends.

How the Candy Is Made

The production process at Hercules is largely manual, which is rare in modern confectionery. For hard candies, the sugar mixture is boiled to about 300°F (hard-crack stage), then flavored and colored. The hot mass is poured onto a marble or steel table, where it is folded and pulled to incorporate air, which affects texture. Workers then roll the candy into ropes and cut it into pieces using a guillotine-style cutter. For filled chocolates, centers are formed first—often using a starch mold—then enrobed in tempered chocolate.

Because the process is labor-intensive, the company produces smaller batches than industrial competitors. This means a shorter shelf life for some items, especially those without preservatives. Most hard candies last several months if stored in a cool, dry place, but chocolate items are best consumed within weeks of purchase.

Buying Direct and Retail Experience

The Hercules Candy retail store, located at the factory on North Salina Street in Syracuse, is a destination for locals and tourists. The store sells:

  • Bulk candy by the pound from open bins
  • Gift boxes and themed assortments
  • Factory seconds at a discount
  • Seasonal novelties for Easter, Christmas, and Valentine’s Day

Customers can also order online through the company’s website, though shipping is limited to certain regions due to heat sensitivity of chocolate. The store’s atmosphere is intentionally old-fashioned, with vintage signage and a counter service style, which reinforces the brand’s historical identity.

Common Questions and Misconceptions

One frequent misconception is that Hercules Candy Company is related to the ancient Greek hero or to the Hercules brand of tools—it is not. The name is purely a marketing choice. Another question is whether the candy is gluten-free; most hard candies are, but chocolate items may contain traces of wheat or nuts, so the company advises checking labels. There is also confusion about the company’s age: some sources say 1919, others 1920; the family uses 1920 as the official founding year.

Another common issue is that hard candies from Hercules sometimes arrive cracked in shipping. This happens because the candy is brittle and not packed with excessive cushioning. The company does not offer a guarantee against breakage, but many customers report that broken pieces still taste fine.

Comparison to Other Regional Candy Makers

Hercules sits in a niche between mass-market brands like Brach’s and artisanal chocolatiers. Compared to Brach’s, Hercules offers a more intense flavor and a firmer texture because of the small-batch cooking process. Compared to high-end chocolatiers, Hercules is less expensive and focuses on quantity and tradition rather than rare ingredients. The closest comparable companies are other Northeastern family operations like the Hammond’s Candies in Denver or the Golden Age of candy in Pennsylvania, but each has its own regional following.

Cost and Value

Prices at Hercules are moderate: a pound of bulk hard candy typically costs $6–$8, while a box of chocolates runs $10–$15 depending on size. This is cheaper than artisanal chocolate but more expensive than supermarket bags. The value proposition is quality and authenticity—customers pay for a product made in small batches with real sugar, not high-fructose corn syrup. For large events like weddings, buying in bulk from the factory store can save money compared to retail shops.

Safety and Storage

Hercules candies are safe for general consumption, but there are a few points to note. The factory is not a nut-free facility, so people with severe allergies should exercise caution. Hard candies are a choking hazard for young children, as with any similar product. For storage, keep hard candy in an airtight container at room temperature; humidity causes stickiness. Chocolate should be stored below 70°F, away from light, to prevent bloom—a gray-white film that is harmless but affects appearance. Do not refrigerate chocolate, as it absorbs odors and changes texture.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Hercules Candy Company still family-owned? Yes, the Mastrodonato family still owns and operates the business, with the third and fourth generations involved in daily operations.

Can I visit the factory? The retail store is open to the public, but the production floor is not always open for tours. You can watch candy being made through a viewing window on certain days, but it is best to call ahead.

Does Hercules Candy contain nuts? Some products do, especially the chocolate assortments. The facility processes nuts, so cross-contamination is possible. Hard candies without chocolate are generally nut-free, but always read the label.

Why does the candy taste different from store brands? Hercules uses real cane sugar and natural flavor oils, and the small-batch cooking process caramelizes the sugar slightly, giving a deeper flavor. Mass-market candies often use corn syrup and artificial flavors, which taste flatter.

How long does the candy last? Hard candies last 6–12 months if kept dry. Chocolate items last 2–3 months at room temperature. Check the “best by” date printed on the package.

Do they ship outside New York State? Yes, but chocolate shipping is limited during warm months. Hard candies ship year-round within the continental United States.

Related

How pages are sourced and corrected: Sources and editorial policy.