OneStopList

Gods and goddesses

Hercules Candy Company: New York’s Oldest Candy Maker

Updated November 21, 2026

Hercules Candy Company is a real, family-owned candy manufacturer located in Syracuse, New York, and it has been operating continuously since 1924. The company is best known for its old-fashioned, small-batch confections, particularly its sponge candy, butter crunch, and molded chocolates, which are made using recipes and equipment that have changed little in nearly a century.

History and Origins in Syracuse

Hercules Candy was founded in 1924 by the three Lamonica brothers, Italian immigrants who settled in Syracuse. The name “Hercules” was chosen to evoke strength and dependability, and the original storefront was located on North Salina Street in the city’s North Side neighborhood. The brothers made candy in copper kettles, a method the company still uses today. Over the decades, the business remained in the Lamonica family, passing from the founders to their children and then grandchildren. The current owner, a third-generation family member, continues to run the operation from a factory on Court Street Road in Syracuse, where the company has been based since the 1980s. Unlike many historic candy brands that were acquired by large corporations, Hercules has stayed independent, which explains its relatively small distribution footprint—most of its sales are local, through its own retail store, farmers’ markets, and a modest online shop.

Signature Products and Recipes

Hercules is most famous for its sponge candy, a brittle, airy confection made from sugar, corn syrup, and baking soda, which creates a honeycomb-like texture when the hot syrup reacts with the soda. The candy is then coated in chocolate—usually milk or dark—and sometimes dusted with nuts. Sponge candy is a regional specialty in western and central New York, and Hercules is one of the few producers that still makes it in small batches. Another flagship item is butter crunch, a toffee-like candy layered with almonds and covered in chocolate. The company also produces molded chocolates in seasonal shapes (bunnies, Santas, hearts) using antique metal molds, as well as hard candies, caramels, fudge, and chocolate-covered pretzels. Many recipes are original to the 1920s, and the company publicly states that it has not changed the core formulas, preferring to keep the same taste that older customers remember from childhood.

How the Candy Is Made

The production process at Hercules is deliberately low-tech. Workers cook sugar, butter, and flavorings in open copper kettles over gas flames, then pour the hot mass onto cooling tables. For sponge candy, the critical step is adding baking soda to the hot syrup, which causes a rapid release of carbon dioxide gas, creating thousands of tiny bubbles. The mixture must be stirred quickly and poured before it sets, which requires skilled timing. After cooling, the slabs are cut into irregular pieces, then enrobed in melted chocolate by hand or through a small tempering machine. The company does not use preservatives or artificial colors in most products, which is why its candies have a shorter shelf life than mass-produced supermarket sweets. Because of the small-scale methods, production runs are limited, and some items are only available during certain seasons—for example, sponge eggs at Easter and peppermint bark in December.

Where to Buy and Pricing

Hercules operates a retail store attached to its factory at 5801 Court Street Road in Syracuse, open Monday through Saturday. Visitors can watch candy being made through large windows, and the store sells factory seconds at a discount, which are pieces that are misshapen or slightly imperfect but taste identical. The company also appears at regional farmers’ markets and local festivals, and it ships nationwide through its website. Prices are typical for artisanal candy: a 12-ounce box of sponge candy costs roughly $12–$15, and a pound of butter crunch is around $16–$18. Shipping is calculated by weight, and the company advises ordering chocolate items only in cooler months unless the customer chooses expedited delivery, since chocolate can melt in transit during summer.

Common Questions and Misconceptions

A frequent assumption is that Hercules Candy is connected to the ancient Greek hero Hercules or to the modern Hercules brand of tools or vehicles—it is not; the name is simply a marketing choice from the 1920s. Another misconception is that sponge candy is a health food because it is airy and light; in reality, it is mostly sugar and butter, with a high calorie density per ounce. Some customers also expect the candy to be gluten-free, and while many items are naturally gluten-free (sponge candy, butter crunch, and plain chocolates), the company does not have a certified gluten-free facility, so cross-contamination is possible. Finally, people often ask whether the company is the same as the famous “Hercules” brand from the 1950s that made licorice—that was a different, unrelated company that no longer exists.

Comparison to Other New York Candy Makers

New York State has several historic candy companies, and Hercules sits in a distinct niche. For example, Barton’s in the Bronx was known for kosher chocolates but closed in the 1990s, while Li-Lac Chocolates in Manhattan has been making hand-dipped chocolates since 1923 and is more upscale and tourist-oriented. Upstate, Fischer’s in Buffalo makes sponge candy as well, but Hercules is older and remains family-run, whereas Fischer’s is now owned by a larger regional group. Compared to national brands like Hershey or Mars, Hercules offers no mass-market distribution, no advertising campaigns, and a much smaller product line. The trade-off is that Hercules provides a taste of early-20th-century candy-making that large factories cannot replicate, because the copper-kettle method produces a distinctive caramelized flavor and a more irregular, handmade texture.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Hercules Candy still in business?

Yes, Hercules Candy Company is still operating in Syracuse, New York, as of 2025. It remains family-owned and continues to make candy using the same copper-kettle methods and many of the same recipes from its founding in 1924.

What is sponge candy and why is it special?

Sponge candy is a brittle confection made by adding baking soda to hot sugar syrup, which creates a porous, honeycomb-like texture. It is a regional specialty in western and central New York, and Hercules is one of the few producers that still makes it in small batches with real chocolate coating.

Does Hercules Candy ship outside New York?

Yes, the company ships nationwide through its website. However, they recommend avoiding shipping chocolate items during hot summer months unless you choose expedited delivery, because the chocolate can melt in transit without temperature-controlled packaging.

Are there any allergens in Hercules products?

Many products contain milk, soy (in chocolate), and nuts, especially almonds in butter crunch and peanut varieties. The facility is not nut-free, and while some items are naturally gluten-free, the company does not claim certified gluten-free status due to potential cross-contamination.

Can I visit the factory and watch candy being made?

Yes, the retail store at 5801 Court Street Road in Syracuse has large viewing windows that let customers watch the candy-making process. The store also sells factory seconds at a discount, which are perfectly edible but slightly misshapen pieces.

Why is the candy more expensive than supermarket brands?

The higher price reflects the use of real butter, fresh cream, and chocolate, as well as the labor-intensive copper-kettle process that produces small batches. There are no preservatives or artificial flavors, and the company does not benefit from economies of scale, so the cost is comparable to other artisanal candy makers.

Related

How pages are sourced and corrected: Sources and editorial policy.