OneStopList

Gods and goddesses

Hercules Candy Company Hard Candy: Real History

Updated November 21, 2026

Hercules Candy Company is a real, family-owned confectionery in Syracuse, New York, and it does make hard candy, though it is best known for its sponge candy and chocolate. The company has operated continuously since 1916, and its hard candies—like butter rum, sour balls, and fruit drops—are made in small batches using traditional open-fire copper kettles.

Company Background and Founding

Hercules Candy Company was founded in 1916 by the Marrone family, immigrants from southern Italy who settled in Syracuse. The name “Hercules” was chosen to evoke strength and reliability, a common marketing tactic of the era. The original shop was a small storefront on North Salina Street, where the family made candies by hand and sold them locally. Over four generations, the business stayed in the Marrone family, with each generation learning the trade from the previous one. Today, the company operates from a larger facility on Court Street Road in Syracuse, but it still uses many of the original recipes and techniques, including copper kettles heated over open gas flames.

What Hard Candies They Make

Hercules produces a range of hard candies, all of which are gluten-free and made without artificial preservatives. Their standard hard candy line includes:

  • Butter Rum – a rich, buttery flavor with a rum note, one of their most popular sellers.
  • Sour Balls – round, brightly colored candies with a tangy coating.
  • Fruit Drops – assorted flavors like cherry, lemon, orange, and lime, often sold in a mixed bag.
  • Peppermint Sticks – traditional red-and-white striped sticks, especially popular around winter holidays.
  • Cinnamon Discs – flat, spicy hard candies with a strong cinnamon kick.

They also make seasonal hard candies, such as candy canes for Christmas and pastel mints for Easter. Unlike mass-produced hard candies that are cooked in continuous vacuum cookers, Hercules batches are cooked in smaller quantities, which gives a slightly different texture—denser and less brittle than commercial versions.

How Hercules Hard Candy Is Made

The process is essentially the same as it was a century ago. Sugar, corn syrup, water, and flavoring are combined in a copper kettle and heated to around 300°F (149°C), the “hard crack” stage. At this temperature, the sugar syrup has very little water left, so when it cools, it forms a glassy, solid mass. The candy maker then pours the hot syrup onto a cooling slab, adds color and flavor, and either pulls it (for opaque candies like butter rum) or leaves it clear (for fruit drops). After cooling, the sheet is scored or broken into pieces, then wrapped by hand or by simple machines.

One detail that sets Hercules apart is that they do not use corn syrup substitutes like isomalt, which many modern candy companies use to reduce cost. This means their hard candy has a more traditional sweetness and melts more slowly in the mouth.

How to Choose Between Their Hard Candy Flavors

If you are new to Hercules hard candy, start with the butter rum, as it is their signature flavor and best represents their old-fashioned style. If you prefer tart flavors, the sour balls are a safe bet. For a classic candy jar staple, the fruit drops offer variety without being too sweet. If you are buying for a holiday gathering, peppermint sticks are the most versatile. When ordering online, note that they sell both individual flavors and assorted bags; the assorted bags usually contain a mix of fruit drops, sour balls, and cinnamon discs, so check the label if you want a specific type.

Common Problems and Misconceptions

A frequent misconception is that “Hercules” is a brand of Greek-themed candy, but it has no connection to the mythological hero beyond the name. Another issue buyers encounter is that hard candy can become sticky or melt if stored in warm, humid conditions. Hercules hard candy is best kept in a cool, dry place, ideally in an airtight container. Some customers also complain that the candy is harder than supermarket brands—that is intentional, because it is cooked to a higher temperature and contains less air. If you have dental work, be cautious: very hard candy can crack fillings, so let it dissolve rather than biting down.

Another common question is whether the candy contains nuts. Most Hercules hard candies are nut-free, but they are made in a facility that also processes nuts for other products, so people with severe allergies should contact the company directly before purchasing.

Cost and Where to Buy

Hercules hard candy is moderately priced, typically around $6 to $10 per pound depending on the flavor and packaging. You can buy it directly from their retail store in Syracuse, from their website, or through third-party online marketplaces. The company also offers bulk discounts for parties, weddings, or candy buffets. Shipping is generally flat-rate within the United States, but international shipping is limited.

Compared to mass-market brands like Jolly Rancher or Werther’s, Hercules hard candy is more expensive per ounce, but it is a premium product with a longer ingredient list (real butter, natural flavors) and a smaller-batch production method. For many customers, the taste difference justifies the price.

Safety and Storage

Hard candy is safe for most people, but it is a choking hazard for young children under age four, so do not give it to toddlers. The candy itself has a very low moisture content, which makes it shelf-stable for up to a year if kept sealed. Once opened, it will absorb humidity and become sticky, so store it in an airtight container. Do not refrigerate hard candy—cold temperatures can cause condensation, which ruins the texture. If the candy develops a white film (called “sugar bloom”), it is still safe to eat but has lost some quality. Always check the “best by” date on the package, though properly stored hard candy can last well beyond that date.

Alternatives to Hercules Hard Candy

If you cannot find Hercules or want similar small-batch hard candy, consider these regional American makers:

  • Abbott’s Candy (Indiana) – known for caramels but also makes hard candy.
  • Brach’s (Illinois) – a larger brand with a wide hard candy range, though not small-batch.
  • Lammes Candies (Texas) – famous for pralines, but also offers hard candy.
  • Old Dominion Peanut Company (Virginia) – makes old-fashioned stick candy.

For a truly similar experience, look for any candy maker that advertises “open-fire cooking” or “kettle-cooked” hard candy, as that method produces the dense, rich texture Hercules is known for.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Hercules Candy Company still family-owned?
Yes, as of the latest public information, it remains owned and operated by the Marrone family, now in its fourth generation.

Does Hercules hard candy contain gelatin or animal products?
No, their hard candies are typically vegan, as they contain only sugar, corn syrup, flavorings, and colorings. However, always check the label, as seasonal varieties might differ.

Why is my hard candy cloudy or white inside?
That is normal for pulled candies like butter rum—the pulling process incorporates tiny air bubbles that make the candy opaque. Clear candies like fruit drops are not pulled, so they remain transparent.

Can I visit the factory in Syracuse?
Yes, Hercules has a retail store at their production facility, and they sometimes offer tours during special events, but regular tours are not guaranteed—call ahead to confirm.

Does Hercules make sugar-free hard candy?
No, they do not currently offer a sugar-free line. If you need sugar-free, look for brands that use isomalt or xylitol.

How long does a piece of Hercules hard candy last in your mouth?
Because it is dense and slow-dissolving, a single piece can last 15 to 20 minutes, depending on how much you suck on it.

Related

How pages are sourced and corrected: Sources and editorial policy.