OneStopList

Gods and goddesses

Broken Sword II: The Smoking Mirror – Plot & Gameplay

Updated November 20, 2026

Broken Sword II: The Smoking Mirror is a 1997 point-and-click adventure game by Revolution Software, the direct sequel to the acclaimed Broken Sword: The Shadow of the Templars. It follows American tourist George Stobbart and French journalist Nico Collard as they investigate a Mayan apocalypse prophecy, a stolen Aztec artifact, and a criminal syndicate called the Neo-Nazis. The game is a full narrative sequel, not a remake or spin-off, and its story is self-contained but builds directly on the characters and tone of the first title.

Story Premise and Setting

The game opens with George in a Paris bookstore, where he is attacked by a masked assailant who steals a rare pre-Columbian codex. The theft draws George and Nico into a plot involving the ancient Maya, the god Tezcatlipoca (the “Smoking Mirror” of the title), and a prophecy that the world will end in 2012. The narrative moves from Paris to the Caribbean island of Quaramonte, then to a Mayan temple complex in Central America, and finally to a hidden underground city. The plot blends real Mesoamerican mythology with fictional conspiracy elements, a hallmark of the series. Notably, the game’s villain is a wealthy industrialist named Don Ricardo, who believes he is the reincarnation of an Aztec ruler and plans to use the artifact to trigger a global catastrophe.

Gameplay Mechanics

Broken Sword II retains the classic point-and-click interface of its predecessor. You control George, and occasionally Nico, by clicking on the screen to move, examine, pick up, and use inventory items. The game uses a verb-coin system: a single icon that changes contextually (walk, look, talk, use) depending on where you point. Puzzles are inventory-based and dialogue-driven, with no timed sequences. The game has a notable feature: you can switch between George and Nico at certain points, each with their own inventory and abilities. This dual-character mechanic is used sparingly but adds variety, particularly in a section where Nico must infiltrate a mansion while George explores a jungle.

Puzzle Design and Difficulty

The puzzles in The Smoking Mirror are generally more obscure and less logical than in the first game. Many require combining items in non-obvious ways, such as using a chocolate bar to grease a mechanism, or using a rubber band and a pencil to create a slingshot. Some puzzles rely on cultural knowledge, like interpreting Mayan numerals or matching glyphs. The game is known for a few infamous difficulty spikes, particularly a maze-like underground river section and a sequence where you must time a leap across a collapsing bridge. Unlike the first game, there is no built-in hint system, so players often rely on walkthroughs. The difficulty is a common point of criticism, but it also rewards patient experimentation and careful examination of the environment.

Visuals, Audio, and Voice Acting

The game uses hand-drawn 2D backgrounds with digitized 3D-rendered characters, a style common in the late 1990s. The art is detailed and atmospheric, with lush jungle scenes, ornate Mayan ruins, and moody underground caverns. The soundtrack, composed by Barrington Pheloung, mixes ambient orchestral pieces with Spanish guitar and percussion, fitting the Mesoamerican theme. The voice acting is a mix of British and American actors; George is voiced by Rolf Saxon, and Nico by Claire Buckfield, both returning from the first game. The dialogue is witty and often self-referential, with George’s sarcastic humor providing levity against the darker plot. The game’s cutscenes are rendered in-engine, and while the animation is dated, the writing remains strong.

Critical Reception and Legacy

Broken Sword II received generally positive reviews at release, with critics praising its story, atmosphere, and voice acting, but some criticized the puzzles as unfair and the pacing as uneven. It sold well enough to justify further sequels, but it is often considered the weakest of the mainline Broken Sword games. The game was re-released on multiple platforms, including PlayStation, Windows, and later on mobile devices and GOG.com. In 2009, a director’s cut of the first game was released, but no such version exists for the sequel. The Smoking Mirror’s legacy is mixed: it is remembered fondly for its ambitious story and beautiful art, but its frustrating puzzles keep it from reaching the heights of its predecessor. It remains playable today on modern systems via digital distribution, and fans of the series often revisit it for its narrative.

Connection to Real Mesoamerican Mythology

The game draws on genuine Aztec and Mayan mythology, though it takes significant liberties. Tezcatlipoca is a real Aztec god, whose name literally means “Smoking Mirror,” and he was associated with the night sky, conflict, and change. The game correctly portrays him as a powerful, sometimes malevolent deity. The prophecy of a world-ending date in 2012 is a modern misinterpretation of the Mayan Long Count calendar, which the game uses as a plot device. The game also features the feathered serpent god Quetzalcoatl, who in Aztec myth is a rival to Tezcatlipoca. While the game’s depiction of these gods is fictionalized, it does introduce players to real mythological names and concepts, which is a point of interest for mythology enthusiasts. The game’s use of a codex (a folding book) is also accurate to Mesoamerican writing, though the specific codex in the game is invented.

Comparison to the First Game

Compared to Broken Sword: The Shadow of the Templars, The Smoking Mirror is shorter (roughly 8-10 hours vs. 12-15) and has a more linear structure. The first game’s conspiracy involved the Knights Templar and historical European mysteries, while the sequel shifts to Mesoamerican lore. The sequel has more action-oriented set pieces, including a chase scene and a mine cart ride, but these are still controlled via point-and-click. The dialogue system is similar, but the sequel offers fewer dialogue options per conversation. The first game is widely considered superior in puzzle logic and story coherence; the sequel’s puzzles are more abstract, and its climax is often described as anticlimactic. However, the sequel’s atmosphere and art direction are arguably more distinctive, with a stronger sense of place in its jungle and temple settings.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need to play the first Broken Sword before this one? It is strongly recommended, but not strictly required. The sequel references events and characters from the first game, especially George and Nico’s relationship, but the main plot is self-contained. Playing the first game will give you background on the characters and the tone, but you can follow the story without it.

Is the game available on modern systems? Yes. Broken Sword II: The Smoking Mirror is available on GOG.com, Steam, and on iOS and Android devices. The mobile versions have updated controls for touchscreens, but the core game is unchanged. The Windows version runs on modern operating systems with a compatibility patch, which is usually pre-applied on digital storefronts.

How long is the game? A typical playthrough takes about 8 to 12 hours, depending on how quickly you solve puzzles. Without a walkthrough, some players report spending 15 hours or more due to the obscure puzzle solutions. The game has no multiple endings, so replay value comes from experiencing the story again.

Why is the game called “The Smoking Mirror”? The title comes from the Aztec god Tezcatlipoca, whose name translates to “Smoking Mirror.” In the game, an obsidian mirror is a key artifact that the villain uses to communicate with the god. The mirror is also a plot device for seeing visions of the future.

Are the Mayan and Aztec elements historically accurate? The game uses real names and concepts, but it fictionalizes them heavily. The 2012 prophecy is a modern myth, not an actual Mayan belief. The game’s depiction of rituals and temples is inspired by real archaeology but is not precise. It is best viewed as a fantasy adventure using mythological dressing, not an educational resource.

Is there a director’s cut or remaster? No. Unlike the first game, which received a director’s cut in 2009, Broken Sword II has never been remastered or re-released with enhanced graphics or added content. The only re-releases are the original version on digital platforms, with minor compatibility fixes.

Related

How pages are sourced and corrected: Sources and editorial policy.