OneStopList

Gods and goddesses

Are We a Divided Nation? Facts and Context

Updated November 18, 2026

Yes, by most measurable indicators, the United States is deeply divided along political, ideological, and cultural lines, though the degree and nature of that division vary by issue and region. Polling data from Pew Research Center and other major survey organizations consistently show widening partisan gaps on core values, trust in institutions, and even basic facts, while geographic sorting and social media echo chambers reinforce these splits. However, the picture is more complex than a simple binary of red versus blue, with significant overlaps on many policy preferences and a majority who believe division is a serious problem.

Historical Background of American Polarization

Partisan conflict is not new in American history. The 1790s saw fierce battles between Federalists and Democratic-Republicans, and the Civil War represented the ultimate failure of political compromise. Yet many political scientists argue that the current era is distinct in its ideological polarization, where parties have become more internally homogeneous and farther apart on a left-right spectrum. In the mid-20th century, conservative Democrats and liberal Republicans were common in Congress, allowing cross-party coalitions on civil rights, environmental laws, and tax policy. By the 1990s and 2000s, however, the parties sorted ideologically, with the South shifting to the GOP and the Northeast and West Coast becoming more Democratic. This sorting accelerated after the 2010 census and the rise of Tea Party and later progressive movements, leading to fewer competitive districts and more primary challenges from the extremes.

How Polarization Is Measured

Researchers use several metrics to track division, each with its own strengths and limitations.

  • Party identification and ideology: The share of Americans who identify as “strong” partisans has risen, while self-described moderates have declined.
  • Ideological distance: The gap between the average Democratic and Republican positions on a composite scale has grown dramatically since the 1970s, as measured by the Pew Research Center’s political typology.
  • Affective polarization: Surveys ask how warm or cold people feel toward the other party’s supporters. These “feeling thermometer” ratings have become more negative, indicating that dislike of the opposing party is not just about policy but about social identity.
  • Legislative voting patterns: The percentage of roll-call votes in Congress that split along party lines (party unity votes) has increased, and the number of moderate members in both chambers has fallen.
  • Geographic sorting: More Americans now live in counties where their preferred party dominates, reducing daily contact with people of the opposite political persuasion.

Key Drivers of Division

Several interlocking factors explain why the nation has become more polarized, and they reinforce each other in ways that make reversal difficult.

  • Media fragmentation: The decline of local newspapers and the rise of cable news and social media allow people to consume information that confirms their biases. A 2020 Pew study found that 55% of Republicans and 45% of Democrats say they get most of their political news from sources that align with their views.
  • Geographic sorting: Since the 1970s, Americans have increasingly moved to areas where neighbors share their politics, a trend documented by political scientists like Bill Bishop in The Big Sort. This reduces cross-cutting conversations and increases the social cost of expressing dissent.
  • Identity politics: Race, religion, and education have become more closely tied to partisanship. For example, white evangelical Protestants are overwhelmingly Republican, while religiously unaffiliated voters lean Democratic. Educational attainment has also become a strong predictor: in 2020, Joe Biden won 55% of college graduates, while Donald Trump won 65% of those without a degree, according to Pew.
  • Institutional distrust: Trust in the federal government has fallen from 77% in 1964 to about 20% today, according to the Pew Research Center. This distrust is asymmetric and feeds into conspiracy theories and refusal to accept election results.

Common Misconceptions About Division

One common misconception is that Americans are divided on everything. In fact, there are many issues where majorities of both parties agree. For example, large majorities support background checks for gun purchases, protecting Medicare and Social Security, and allowing same-sex marriage (though the latter has become less partisan in recent years). Another misconception is that polarization is purely a mass phenomenon; in reality, the mass public is less polarized than political elites. However, the most politically engaged citizens are the most polarized, and they are the ones who vote in primaries and donate to campaigns, which pushes parties further apart. A third misconception is that social media is the primary cause; while it amplifies division, studies show that polarization began increasing before the internet era, suggesting deeper structural causes.

Consequences of a Divided Nation

The effects of polarization extend beyond elections. Congress has become less productive, with fewer laws passed and more frequent government shutdowns. Trust in institutions, including the Supreme Court and the media, has declined, and partisan violence has become a concern: the FBI reported a rise in threats against public officials, and the January 6, 2021, attack on the Capitol was the most dramatic example. Polarization also affects personal relationships, with some families avoiding political discussions at holidays. On the positive side, high levels of polarization can increase political engagement and voter turnout, as people feel the stakes are higher. Yet the negative consequences—gridlock, affective hostility, and democratic backsliding—are more prominent in current scholarship.

Comparisons with Other Democracies

The United States is not alone in experiencing polarization, but the pattern differs. In many European countries, multiparty systems allow for coalition governments, which can moderate extremes. The UK has seen increased polarization over Brexit, but its parliamentary system often forces compromise. In contrast, the US two-party system, combined with primaries that reward ideological purity, creates incentives for polarization. Additionally, the US has a presidential system with checks and balances, which can lead to gridlock when different parties control the presidency and Congress. Comparative studies, such as those by political scientists like Yphtach Lelkes, suggest that while other democracies have also seen rising affective polarization, the US is among the most polarized in terms of ideological distance between parties.

What Can Be Done?

There is no single solution, but scholars and practitioners have proposed several approaches.

  • Electoral reforms: Independent redistricting commissions, ranked-choice voting, and open primaries could reduce the number of safe seats and encourage candidates to appeal to a broader electorate.
  • Civic education: Programs that teach media literacy and critical thinking may help citizens resist misinformation and reduce hostility toward out-groups.
  • Intergroup contact: Initiatives that bring together people from different political backgrounds, such as Better Angels workshops, have shown modest success in reducing affective polarization.
  • Institutional changes: Reforming the Senate filibuster, which requires 60 votes to pass most legislation, could reduce gridlock, though it is a controversial change.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the US more divided now than during the Civil War?

No. The Civil War was a literal armed conflict over slavery and secession, with over 600,000 deaths. Current polarization is severe, but it does not involve widespread armed conflict, and most Americans reject violence as a political tool. However, the January 6 attack and increased threats against officials suggest that a minority is willing to use force.

Are Americans actually divided on policy, or just on identity?

Both. On many specific policies, such as raising the minimum wage or protecting the environment, majorities of both parties agree. But on cultural issues like abortion, gun control, and immigration, the gaps are large and growing. Additionally, affective polarization means that even when policy preferences overlap, people dislike the opposing party as a social group.

Does social media cause polarization?

Research is mixed. Some studies, like those by the Pew Research Center, show that heavy social media users are more polarized, but others argue that the causal direction is unclear. A 2020 study by researchers at Stanford and NYU found that deactivating Facebook for a month reduced political polarization, but only slightly. It is likely that social media amplifies existing divisions rather than being the root cause.

Can gerrymandering be blamed for polarization?

Gerrymandering affects which candidates win elections, but it is not the main driver of polarization in Congress. Polarization has increased even in states with nonpartisan redistricting commissions. The primary cause is the geographic sorting of voters: Democrats and Republicans increasingly live in different districts, making it harder for moderates to win.

Are young people less divided than older generations?

No. Millennials and Gen Z are more polarized than previous generations were at their age, according to Pew Research Center data. They are more likely to identify with a party and to have negative views of the other party. However, they are also more supportive of compromise and less likely to see political differences as a threat to democracy.

Related

How pages are sourced and corrected: Sources and editorial policy.