Apollo Bagels and Pop Up Bagels are two distinct New York City bagel operations, and the clearest difference is that Apollo Bagels is a brick-and-mortar shop with a devoted following for its traditional, hand-rolled bagels, while Pop Up Bagels is a delivery-only brand known for its creative, often over-the-top flavors and viral social media presence. Choosing between them comes down to whether you prioritize classic, crusty, chewy bagels or inventive, dessert-like creations delivered to your door.
Background and Origins
Apollo Bagels opened in 2021 in the East Village, founded by a team that includes a former baker from the renowned Sadelle’s and a co-founder of the popular online food community. The shop quickly gained a reputation for its old-school approach: bagels are hand-rolled, boiled, and baked in small batches throughout the day, with a focus on traditional flavors like sesame, everything, and plain. Its interior is minimal, with a counter and a few stools, and lines often stretch out the door on weekends.
Pop Up Bagels, on the other hand, started in 2020 as a virtual brand operating out of a commissary kitchen in Manhattan. It was founded by a former finance professional who saw a gap in the market for delivery-only bagels with a modern twist. The brand exploded on TikTok and Instagram thanks to visually striking creations like the “Cinnamon Crunch” and “Cookies and Cream” bagels, which are stuffed with fillings and topped with sweet glazes. It has no storefront; customers order exclusively through its website or delivery apps.
How Each Makes Its Bagels
The production methods differ significantly, which directly affects texture and taste.
- Apollo Bagels: Uses a high-gluten flour, a sourdough starter, and a 24-hour cold fermentation. The dough is hand-rolled, boiled in a honey-water solution, and then baked in a traditional deck oven. This creates a dense, chewy interior with a shiny, crisp crust.
- Pop Up Bagels: Also uses a sourdough starter and cold fermentation, but the bagels are baked in a convection oven after being boiled. The dough is slightly softer, and the bagels are often larger and fluffier, which makes them better suited for holding heavy toppings and fillings.
Apollo’s process yields a more traditional New York bagel—hefty, malty, and with a pronounced chew. Pop Up’s process produces a lighter, sweeter bagel that leans toward a brioche-like texture, especially in its flavored varieties.
Flavors and Menu Offerings
Apollo’s menu is deliberately short and classic. You’ll find plain, sesame, poppy, everything, cinnamon raisin, and a few seasonal specials. Sandwiches are simple, like lox with cream cheese, capers, and red onion, or an egg and cheese on a roll. The focus is on the quality of the bagel itself, not on elaborate toppings.
Pop Up Bagels, by contrast, is known for its extensive and whimsical menu. In addition to classic flavors, it offers a rotating lineup of sweet bagels such as “Fruity Pebbles,” “S’mores,” and “Birthday Cake,” each with a corresponding cream cheese or filling. Savory options include “Jalapeño Cheddar” and “Everything with Scallion Cream Cheese.” The brand also sells “bagel bombs”—miniature stuffed bagels—and a line of signature schmears. This makes Pop Up a go-to for those seeking a dessert-like treat or a fun, shareable experience.
Price and Availability
Apollo Bagels charges around $3 for a plain bagel and $12–$15 for a sandwich, which is typical for a premium New York bagel shop. It operates from early morning until sold out, usually by early afternoon, and is located at 86 East 7th Street in Manhattan. You can walk in and order, but there is no delivery.
Pop Up Bagels is more expensive due to the delivery model and specialty ingredients. A single bagel costs about $4–$6, and a bagel with schmear or filling can run $8–$12. Delivery is available throughout Manhattan and parts of Brooklyn and Queens, with a minimum order of $25. The brand also ships its bagels nationwide via its website, which is something Apollo does not offer.
How to Choose Between Them
Your choice depends on what you value most in a bagel experience.
- If you want a classic, authentic New York bagel with a hard crust and chewy crumb, and you’re willing to wait in line, choose Apollo.
- If you want a convenient, delivery-only option with creative, dessert-like flavors and don’t mind paying a premium, choose Pop Up.
- If you’re hosting a brunch or want to try something visually impressive, Pop Up’s stuffed bagels are more likely to be a conversation starter.
- If you’re a purist who believes a bagel should only have seeds or salt on top, Apollo is the safer bet.
Common Problems and Misconceptions
A frequent misconception is that Pop Up Bagels is a traditional bagel shop; it is not—it’s a virtual brand, so you can’t visit a storefront. Another is that Apollo’s bagels are “too hard” or “overcooked” because of their crust; in reality, that crust is a hallmark of a properly boiled and baked bagel. Some customers also complain about Pop Up’s long delivery times, which can exceed an hour during peak hours, and its high shipping costs for nationwide orders. For Apollo, the main issue is availability: it often sells out by early afternoon, so late risers miss out.
Alternatives Worth Considering
If neither of these fits your needs, New York City has other notable bagel options. Ess-a-Bagel (multiple locations) is famous for its large, hand-rolled bagels and extensive spreads. Russ & Daughters (Lower East Side) is a legendary appetizing store with a café that serves excellent bagels with high-quality lox. Absolute Bagels (Upper West Side) is a cash-only hole-in-the-wall with a cult following for its perfectly balanced bagels. For a delivery-only alternative similar to Pop Up, Bagel Market offers a wide range of flavors and ships nationwide.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Apollo bagels really sourdough?
Yes, Apollo uses a sourdough starter in its dough, which gives the bagels a subtle tang and a longer shelf life. This is a common technique in artisan bagel shops, though the sourness is mild compared to sourdough bread.
Can I order Pop Up Bagels for pickup?
No, Pop Up Bagels is delivery-only. You cannot pick up an order in person because there is no storefront. All orders are placed online or through delivery apps.
Which bagel is healthier?
It depends on the flavor. Apollo’s plain or sesame bagels are lower in sugar and calories than Pop Up’s sweet varieties, which can have added sugars and glazes. A plain bagel from either shop is comparable, but Pop Up’s dessert options are significantly higher in sugar.
Do either of these shops offer gluten-free options?
Neither Apollo nor Pop Up offers gluten-free bagels at this time. Both use wheat flour exclusively, so they are not suitable for those with celiac disease or gluten sensitivity.
Which is better for a traditional lox sandwich?
Apollo is the better choice for a classic lox sandwich because its dense, chewy bagel holds up well to cream cheese and smoked fish, and its simple toppings let the lox shine. Pop Up’s sweeter or heavily flavored bagels can overpower the delicate taste of lox.
Related
- Athena Club Golden Vanilla Lotion: What It Is
- Apollo Bagels New York: Real Bagels & How to Order
- Greek Mythology Zeus Story: Origins, Power, Myths
How pages are sourced and corrected: Sources and editorial policy.