Alien: Prometheus holds a 73% Tomatometer score on Rotten Tomatoes based on over 300 critic reviews, while its Audience Score sits lower at 68%. These numbers reflect a genuinely divided reception: critics praised the film’s visuals and ambition, while many viewers found its plot holes and character decisions frustrating. The film is not part of the original Alien trilogy’s critical consensus, but it remains a commercially successful and visually stunning entry in the franchise.
Background: Where Prometheus Fits in the Alien Franchise
Released in 2012, Prometheus was directed by Ridley Scott, who also directed the original 1979 Alien. The film was conceived as a prequel, but Scott and writer Damon Lindelof intentionally left it as a standalone story that shares the same universe. It follows the crew of the spaceship Prometheus as they search for the “Engineers,” an advanced alien species believed to have created humanity. The film does not feature the iconic Xenomorph directly, instead introducing the parasitic “Deacon” creature in its final scene. This creative choice divided fans who expected a direct lead-in to the original film.
How Rotten Tomatoes Scores Are Calculated
Rotten Tomatoes separates its scores into two categories: the Tomatometer (critics) and the Audience Score. The Tomatometer is a simple percentage of critics who gave the film a positive review (typically 3.5 stars or higher out of 5). For Prometheus, 73% of the sampled critics liked it, meaning it received a “Fresh” certification. The Audience Score is based on user ratings, where users rate the film on a 5-star scale; anything above 3.5 stars counts as positive. The 68% audience score indicates a noticeable gap, meaning a significant portion of general viewers were less enthusiastic than critics. It is important to note that Rotten Tomatoes does not average scores—it only counts the proportion of positive reviews.
Why Critics and Audiences Disagree
The critical consensus praised Prometheus for its ambitious themes, stunning cinematography, and Michael Fassbender’s performance as the android David. Many reviewers called it a thought-provoking science fiction film that asked big questions about creation and faith. However, the audience backlash focused on the script’s logical inconsistencies. Common complaints included:
- Scientists making inexplicably foolish decisions, such as removing helmets on an unknown planet.
- The unexplained behavior of the Engineers, whose motives are never clearly defined.
- A muddled third act that rushes to a climax without resolving key plot threads.
- The lack of a direct connection to the Alien timeline, which disappointed franchise purists.
This divide is a classic example of “critics vs. fans,” where critics evaluate artistic merit while audiences prioritize narrative coherence and entertainment value.
Comparing Prometheus to Other Alien Films
To understand the score, it helps to compare it with the rest of the franchise on Rotten Tomatoes:
- Alien (1979) – 98% Tomatometer, 90% Audience Score. Widely considered a masterpiece.
- Aliens (1986) – 97% Tomatometer, 94% Audience Score. A near-perfect sequel.
- Alien 3 (1992) – 44% Tomatometer, 50% Audience Score. A critical and fan disappointment.
- Alien Resurrection (1997) – 55% Tomatometer, 42% Audience Score. Generally disliked.
- Prometheus (2012) – 73% Tomatometer, 68% Audience Score. A middle-ground reception.
- Alien: Covenant (2017) – 65% Tomatometer, 55% Audience Score. The direct sequel to Prometheus.
This shows that Prometheus is actually one of the better-received films in the franchise after the first two, despite the vocal online criticism.
Common Misconceptions About the Score
One frequent misconception is that the 73% means the film is “good” or “bad” in an absolute sense. In reality, it only means that roughly three out of four critics recommended it. Another misconception is that the Audience Score is more “honest” than the Tomatometer. In practice, audience scores on Rotten Tomatoes are vulnerable to review bombing and self-selection bias—people who strongly disliked the film are more likely to rate it than those who were merely satisfied. Additionally, the film’s director’s cut, released on home media, added roughly 30 minutes of deleted scenes that clarified some plot points, but the theatrical version is what the scores reflect. Many viewers who watched the extended cut report a better experience, but that version has no separate Rotten Tomatoes score.
How to Decide Whether to Watch It
If you are deciding whether to watch Prometheus, consider what you value in a film:
- If you enjoy visually spectacular, thematically ambitious sci-fi with philosophical undertones, you will likely appreciate it.
- If you are a hardcore Alien fan expecting a straightforward prequel with Xenomorphs, you may be disappointed.
- If you are sensitive to plot holes or characters acting illogically, the film will frustrate you.
- If you have seen Alien: Covenant already, Prometheus provides essential backstory to that film’s events.
It is also worth noting that the film’s visuals hold up well, and the production design is widely praised. The performance of Fassbender as David is often cited as the best element, and it sets up a compelling arc that continues in the sequel.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Prometheus a direct prequel to Alien?
No, it is a loose prequel. It takes place in the same universe and explains the origin of the Engineers, but it does not directly set up the events of the 1979 film. The sequel Alien: Covenant moves closer to the original timeline, but Prometheus itself is a standalone story.
Why did the scientists in Prometheus act so stupidly?
This is a common criticism. The script intentionally placed the characters in situations where their curiosity overrides caution, but many viewers found the behavior implausible for trained scientists. The director’s cut adds scenes that provide more context for some decisions, but the theatrical version leaves them unexplained.
What is the “Engineer” species?
The Engineers are an ancient, humanoid alien race that created humanity using their own DNA. They are shown in the opening scene of Prometheus sacrificing one of their own to seed life on Earth. Their motives for later wanting to destroy humanity are never fully explained, which is a major unresolved plot thread.
Does Prometheus have a post-credits scene?
No, the film does not have a post-credits scene. The final scene with the Deacon creature occurs just before the credits roll, and there is nothing after the credits.
Is the 73% score considered “fresh” or “rotten”?
A score above 60% is considered “Fresh” on Rotten Tomatoes, so 73% is officially Fresh. However, it is not “Certified Fresh,” which requires a higher threshold and a minimum number of reviews from top critics.
Should I watch the theatrical or director’s cut?
If you are watching for the first time, the director’s cut is generally recommended by fans because it adds character development and clarifies some plot points. However, the theatrical cut is the one that received the Rotten Tomatoes scores, so your experience may differ from the reviews.
Related
- Dionysus Origin Myth: Birth, Death, and Rebirth
- Demeter Holy Smoke: What It Smells Like & More
- Ares vs Ares 2.0: Greek War God Explained
How pages are sourced and corrected: Sources and editorial policy.