OneStopList

Gods and goddesses

Hercules Candy Syracuse NY: A Sweet Legacy

Updated November 21, 2026

Hercules Candy in Syracuse, NY, is a historic family-owned candy manufacturer and retail store known for its old-fashioned chocolates, fudge, and novelty sweets, operating continuously since 1928. Located at 5803 East Taft Road in North Syracuse, it serves both walk-in customers and wholesale accounts across the region.

History of Hercules Candy

The company was founded in 1928 by the Hercules family (no relation to the mythological hero), starting as a small confectionery shop. Over the decades, it survived the Great Depression, wartime sugar rationing, and the rise of mass-produced candy by sticking to traditional recipes and small-batch methods. The current owners, the DeMore family, purchased the business in the 1980s and have maintained the original copper kettles and marble slabs for making fudge and creams. The store’s vintage signage and interior evoke a 1950s candy shop, which is part of its local charm. Today, it remains one of the few independent candy makers left in Central New York, with many customers recalling childhood visits.

What They Make and Sell

Hercules Candy produces a wide range of confections on-site. Their signature items include:

  • Homemade fudge – made daily in flavors like chocolate, peanut butter, and maple walnut.
  • Molded chocolates – solid and filled pieces, including buttercreams, caramels, and nut clusters.
  • Sponge candy – a brittle honeycomb coated in chocolate, a regional favorite.
  • Novelty items – chocolate bunnies, Santas, and holiday-themed pops.
  • Bulk bins – old-fashioned hard candies, gummies, and licorice by the pound.

They also offer sugar-free options for diabetics, and seasonal assortments for Easter, Valentine’s Day, and Christmas. The retail store sells gift boxes, baskets, and custom orders for weddings or corporate events.

How the Candy Is Made

Production follows traditional methods rather than automated lines. For example, their buttercreams are hand-dipped in tempered chocolate using a fork and a marble slab. Fudge is cooked in open copper kettles, then beaten by hand on a cooling table to achieve the proper creamy texture. Sponge candy is made by mixing sugar, corn syrup, and baking soda, which creates air bubbles when heated; the result is then coated in chocolate within hours to preserve crunch. Because batches are small, recipes can be adjusted for texture or flavor without stopping a conveyor belt. Visitors can sometimes watch candy-making through a window into the production room, especially on weekday mornings.

Visiting the Store

The store at 5803 East Taft Road is open Monday through Saturday (hours vary seasonally, so checking their Facebook page is wise). Free parking is available in front. Inside, you’ll find a counter for custom orders, shelves of packaged candies, and a freezer with ice cream (they sell sundaes and milkshakes in summer). They accept cash, credit, and debit; no checks. While the store is not wheelchair-inaccessible (it’s a single floor with wide aisles), the historic building has a step at the entrance. For those unable to visit, they ship across the U.S. via UPS, though shipping chocolate in summer is discouraged due to melting—they offer insulated packaging for an extra fee.

Common Questions and Misconceptions

A frequent misconception is that Hercules Candy is related to the Greek hero or the 1997 Disney film; it is not—the name comes from the founding family. Another is that they sell only chocolate; in fact, they carry a large selection of hard candies, jellies, and sugar-free items. Some visitors expect a factory tour, but the production area is small and not open for guided walks; you can only view it through the window. Also, while they do wholesale to local grocery stores and diners, the retail store is the primary point of sale, and not all products are available at outside retailers.

Comparing to Other Local Candy Shops

Within Syracuse, Hercules competes with a few other confectioners. Fudge Works (in Destiny USA mall) focuses on fudge and chocolate-dipped treats but does not make molded novelties on-site. Sweet Praxis is a small-batch chocolate maker with a modern aesthetic, offering bean-to-bar products—a different niche from Hercules’s nostalgic style. Byrne Dairy stores sell some local chocolates but not fresh-made. What sets Hercules apart is its longevity, the variety of old-fashioned items (like nonpareils and orange slices), and the hands-on, small-batch process. Prices are moderate: a quarter-pound of fudge costs around $4–$5, and a box of assorted chocolates runs $12–$20 depending on size.

Costs and Ordering

Retail prices are typical for artisan candy, not cheap bulk. A pound of fudge is roughly $12–$15. Molded chocolates are sold by piece (about $1.50–$2.50 each) or in pre-boxed assortments. Custom wedding favors (e.g., personalized chocolate bars) have a minimum order of 50 pieces, and you should place orders at least two weeks in advance for holidays. For shipping, they charge based on weight and destination, using USPS Priority or UPS Ground; a 1-pound box to a nearby state costs about $10–$15. They do not offer online ordering on their website—you must call or visit in person to place an order, which surprises many out-of-town customers.

Safety and Storage of Their Products

As a food business, Hercules Candy follows NYS Department of Health regulations. Their chocolates contain dairy, soy, and nuts; they label allergens on packages but do not have a dedicated nut-free facility, so cross-contamination is possible. For storage, keep chocolate in a cool, dry place (60–70°F) away from sunlight; refrigerating is not recommended as it causes bloom (white streaks) and changes texture. Fudge can be kept at room temperature for up to two weeks in an airtight container, or frozen for up to three months. Sponge candy is best eaten within a week of purchase, as it absorbs moisture and becomes sticky. If you receive a shipped order in summer, let it sit unopened for an hour before eating to avoid condensation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Hercules Candy still in business? Yes, as of 2024, it operates at the same North Syracuse location, with regular retail hours and active holiday production.

Do they make sugar-free candy? Yes, they offer a selection of sugar-free chocolates and hard candies, though not every flavor is available daily—call ahead to confirm.

Can I get a tour of the factory? No, but you can watch candy-making through a viewing window during operating hours, typically Monday–Friday mornings.

Do they sell online? They do not have an e-commerce site, but you can call the store to place a phone order for pickup or shipping.

What is their most popular item? The chocolate sponge candy and the hand-dipped buttercreams are local favorites, often selling out on weekends.

Is there parking? Yes, free parking is available in the store’s lot, with additional street parking nearby.

Related

How pages are sourced and corrected: Sources and editorial policy.