NASA’s Artemis missions do not have a single “toilet issue” but rather a series of engineering challenges around managing human waste in the low-gravity environment of the Moon and in the Orion spacecraft during transit. The core problem is that the Artemis program uses two different toilet systems—one for the Orion capsule and one for the lunar lander—and neither works exactly like a bathroom on Earth. The most publicly discussed issue occurred during the uncrewed Artemis I mission in 2022, when the Orion capsule’s toilet was tested with simulated human waste, and engineers discovered that the urine collection system did not fully contain the liquid in microgravity, leading to a redesign for Artemis II.
Why Space Toilets Are So Complicated
In microgravity, fluids do not fall; they float and form spheres that cling to surfaces. A standard gravity-fed toilet is useless. Space toilets use airflow to pull waste away from the body, relying on a fan that creates a suction current. Urine is collected through a funnel and hose, while solid waste is captured in a small bag that is then compacted and stored. On the Moon, the gravity is about one-sixth of Earth’s, which is enough to make waste fall, but not enough to make it behave as it does on Earth. Dust and fine lunar regolith also stick to everything, including waste bags, which complicates disposal.
The Artemis program’s Orion spacecraft uses a toilet built by Collins Aerospace, which is similar in design to the one on the International Space Station (ISS) but lighter and more compact. The lunar lander, however, will use a different system, possibly a simpler bag-based approach, because the lander has less space and power. This dual-system approach means astronauts must learn two different procedures, increasing the risk of user error.
The Artemis I Toilet Failure and Its Fix
During the 25-day Artemis I mission, the Orion capsule flew without a crew, but NASA included a mannequin named Commander Moonikin Campos and two phantom torsos to measure radiation and vibration. The toilet was installed and tested with a special fluid that simulated urine. According to NASA engineers, the test revealed that the urine collection funnel and hose did not maintain a consistent seal, allowing simulated urine to leak into the capsule’s interior. The problem was traced to the hose connection and the fan speed, which was too low to overcome the surface tension of the fluid.
NASA’s response was to redesign the urine hose and funnel for Artemis II, adding a quick-disconnect fitting and increasing the fan’s suction. The agency also added a secondary containment bag around the toilet to catch any future leaks. Jim Free, NASA’s associate administrator for exploration systems development, confirmed in 2023 that the Artemis II toilet would be ready after these modifications. The fix was tested in a parabolic aircraft that simulates microgravity, and NASA reported that the new design worked as intended.
How the Artemis Toilet Works in Practice
Astronauts on Orion will use a toilet that separates liquid and solid waste. For urine, they use a funnel attached to a hose; the funnel has a fan that pulls the urine into a tank. For solid waste, they sit on a seat that has a small opening; a bag is inserted beneath, and a fan draws the waste into the bag. After use, the bag is sealed and stored in a container that is later disposed of during the mission. The urine is not recycled on Orion; it is vented overboard or stored. On the lunar surface, the lander will likely use a simpler system: a commode with a bag that is sealed and left on the Moon, or possibly a portable toilet that fits inside the spacesuit for extravehicular activities.
Astronauts also have to manage waste during spacewalks. For Artemis moonwalks, NASA has developed a new spacesuit called the Axiom Extravehicular Mobility Unit (AxEMU), which includes a diaper-like garment for urine and feces. These garments are not new—they have been used since the Apollo program—but the AxEMU version is designed to hold more waste for longer moonwalks, which can last up to eight hours.
Common Problems and Misconceptions
One common misconception is that astronauts simply “hold it” during short missions. In reality, they cannot, because the human body produces waste continuously. Another misconception is that space toilets are unreliable and frequently break. While the ISS toilet has had occasional malfunctions, the Artemis system is designed with redundancy. The most common problem is user error: astronauts must practice using the toilet in a simulator, but microgravity makes it difficult to align the body correctly. The funnel for urine is designed for both male and female anatomy, but it still requires careful positioning to avoid leaks.
Another issue is that the toilet’s fan can be noisy and produce a slight vibration, which can be uncomfortable. Also, the urine tank must be vented periodically to prevent pressure buildup, and this venting can release small amounts of urine ice crystals into space, which could potentially contaminate the spacecraft’s exterior. NASA has addressed this by placing the vent on the side of the capsule, away from the docking port.
Comparing Artemis Toilets to Apollo and ISS
The Apollo missions used a much simpler system: a plastic bag that was taped to the astronaut’s body, with a gel inside to contain feces. Urine was collected in a condom-like device that drained into a bag. These systems were uncomfortable and prone to leaks. The ISS toilet, which has been in use since 2000, is a large, complex unit that recycles urine into drinking water. The Artemis Orion toilet is smaller and lighter, but it does not recycle urine; it stores it and later vents it. This is a trade-off: recycling requires more power and machinery, which Orion does not have.
The lunar lander toilet will be even simpler, possibly a bag with a gel that solidifies waste. This is because the lander will only be used for a few days, and there is no need to recycle water. For long-term lunar bases, however, NASA is planning to develop a more advanced system that can recycle water and compost waste, but that is not part of the Artemis III mission.
Cost and Development of the Artemis Toilet
NASA has not publicly itemized the cost of the Artemis toilet, but the overall Orion spacecraft development cost billions of dollars. The toilet itself is a small part of that. Collins Aerospace, which builds the toilet, has not released a specific price. However, the redesign after Artemis I likely added several million dollars to the program, as it required new tooling and testing. For comparison, the ISS toilet cost about $19 million to develop in the 1990s, but that included the urine recycling system. The Artemis toilet is simpler, so it is likely cheaper, but still a significant engineering investment.
Safety and Hygiene Considerations
Safety is a major concern because waste can contain harmful bacteria and gases. The toilet system must prevent any leakage into the cabin, as that could cause health issues. The bags used for solid waste are made of a special material that contains odors and prevents microbial growth. Astronauts also use disinfectant wipes to clean the toilet after each use. In the event of a toilet failure, astronauts have a backup: they can use the same bags used for spacewalks, which are stored in a kit. NASA trains astronauts for this contingency.
Another safety issue is that the urine tank can become a projectile if it is not properly secured. The tank is stored in a compartment, but if it is overfilled, it could burst. NASA has a pressure relief valve that vents excess gas, but astronauts must monitor the tank’s fill level. The Artemis II mission will have a crew of four, so the tank will need to be emptied or vented more frequently than on a single-person mission.
Alternatives and Future Developments
NASA is exploring alternatives to the current toilet design for future Artemis missions. One option is a vacuum-based toilet that uses a rotating separator to collect urine without a funnel. Another is a “universal” toilet that can be used by both men and women without needing different attachments. The agency is also researching how to recycle urine into water on the lunar surface, which would reduce the need to carry water from Earth. For long-duration missions to Mars, NASA is working on a system that uses heat and pressure to break down waste into methane and water, but that is still in the experimental stage.
Private companies like SpaceX are also developing their own toilets for the Starship, which could be used for Artemis missions. SpaceX’s Starship human landing system will include a toilet, but the design has not been publicly detailed. It is likely to be similar to the Orion system, but with more space and potentially a recycling capability.
Frequently Asked Questions
Did the Artemis I toilet actually break? No, it did not break, but it leaked during testing. The toilet was not used by a crew, so the leak was discovered through simulated urine. NASA fixed the issue before Artemis II.
Can astronauts use the toilet during launch and landing? Yes, but they wear a diaper-like garment called a Maximum Absorbency Garment (MAG) during launch and landing, because they are strapped into their seats and cannot move to the toilet. The MAG is also used during spacewalks.
How do female astronauts use the Artemis toilet? The urine funnel is designed to be unisex; it has a soft, flexible rim that can be positioned against the body. For solid waste, the seat is the same for all astronauts. NASA has tested the toilet with both male and female test subjects in microgravity.
Is the toilet the same on the lunar lander? No, the lander will have a different, simpler toilet. The Orion toilet is for the trip to and from the Moon, while the lander toilet is for the few days on the surface. The lander toilet may be a bag-based system that is disposed of on the Moon.
What happens to the waste? On Orion, urine is stored in a tank and later vented overboard. Solid waste is compacted and stored in a container that is disposed of before reentry. On the lunar lander, waste bags will be left on the Moon, which is a concern for future missions because it could contaminate lunar science sites. NASA is considering a policy to collect and return waste from the Moon.
Related
- The Smoking Mirror Chapter 3: Summary and Context
- Are Kitchen Sink Sprayers Universal? Sizes & Fits
- Ares Japan Office: Myth, Name, and Modern Use
How pages are sourced and corrected: Sources and editorial policy.