OneStopList

Gods and goddesses

Eternal Flame Waterfall NY: Facts & How to Visit

Updated November 19, 2026

Yes, the Eternal Flame Waterfall is a real, publicly accessible waterfall in Orchard Park, New York, located within Chestnut Ridge Park. It is a small waterfall beneath which a natural gas leak keeps a flame burning continuously, creating the illusion of a waterfall made of fire.

Location and How to Get There

The Eternal Flame Waterfall is found in Erie County, about 20 miles south of Buffalo. The most common access point is the parking lot at the end of Chestnut Ridge Road in Orchard Park. From the lot, a well-trodden trail leads downhill to the creek. The hike is roughly one mile round trip and moderately easy, though the final descent to the waterfall involves a steep, rocky slope that can be slippery, especially after rain.

Visitors should note that the waterfall is not visible from the parking area. You must follow the trail markers for the “Eternal Flame” specifically, as the park has several other trails. The path follows the creek bed for part of the way, so waterproof footwear is strongly recommended.

Why the Flame Never Goes Out

The flame is sustained by natural gas—primarily methane—that seeps out of the shale bedrock beneath the waterfall. The gas originates from the Rhinestreet Shale, a deep geological formation in the Appalachian Basin. Over millions of years, organic matter decomposed and transformed into natural gas, which now slowly migrates upward through fractures in the rock.

At the waterfall, the gas escapes through a small opening in the creek bed. The flame is typically ignited by visitors with a lighter or match, but once lit, it can burn for a very long time because the gas supply is constant. The water flowing over the rock does not extinguish it because the gas pocket sits slightly behind and above the main water flow, shielded from the falling water.

Geological Context and the Shale Connection

This natural gas seep is not unique to New York, but the Eternal Flame is one of the most accessible examples. Similar seeps occur in Pennsylvania, Ohio, and West Virginia, all tied to the same Marcellus and Rhinestreet shale formations. The gas is thermogenic, meaning it was created by heat and pressure deep underground, not by recent biological decomposition.

Geologists have studied this site because it demonstrates natural gas migration in real time. The flame itself is relatively small—usually a few inches to a foot high—but it can vary with gas pressure and water level. During high water, the flame may be partially hidden or even extinguished temporarily, but it often relights on its own if a spark remains.

What to Expect When You Visit

The waterfall itself is modest, perhaps 30 feet high, but the setting is scenic and peaceful. The flame sits at the base, behind a curtain of water. To see it clearly, you may need to step behind the falls, which is possible in dry conditions. The area is popular on weekends, so go early or on a weekday for a quieter experience.

Important practical points:

  • No entrance fee—Chestnut Ridge Park is free to enter.
  • No restrooms near the trailhead; use facilities at the main park area.
  • Dogs are allowed on a leash.
  • Do not attempt to climb the wet rocks directly under the falls.
  • Bring a lighter or matches if you want to relight the flame, as it sometimes goes out.

Safety and Environmental Considerations

The main hazard is the steep, uneven trail. Several visitors have reported slips and minor injuries, especially when the path is muddy. Wear sturdy hiking shoes with good tread, and consider trekking poles. The creek crossing near the falls can be cold and fast-moving in spring; do not cross if the water is above your knees.

From an environmental standpoint, the flame is a natural phenomenon, but human interaction has an impact. Do not leave trash, and avoid damming the creek to create a pool, as some visitors have done. The gas seep itself is harmless, but the area around it can be slippery from mineral deposits. Also, be aware that the flame can be extinguished by heavy rain or flooding; if it is out, you can relight it, but do so carefully with a long lighter to avoid burning your hand.

Comparing to Other Eternal Flames

New York’s Eternal Flame is often compared to the one at Shale Creek Preserve in nearby Chestnut Ridge, but that is the same site. More famous comparisons include the Eternal Flame Falls in Orchard Park (same location) and the natural gas flame at the “Burning Springs” in West Virginia, which is larger but less picturesque. Another well-known example is the “Door to Hell” in Turkmenistan, but that is a collapsed gas crater, not a waterfall, and is far larger and more dangerous.

What makes the New York site special is the combination of a waterfall and flame in one small, accessible spot. Most other natural gas seeps are not near flowing water, so the visual contrast is unique in the eastern United States.

Best Time to Visit and Photography Tips

The flame is visible year-round, but the experience changes with the seasons. In winter, ice may partially cover the falls, and the flame creates a striking blue-orange glow against the snow. In summer, the foliage is lush, but the trail can be buggy. Early spring and late autumn offer the clearest views and the most stable flame, as water levels are moderate.

For photography, bring a tripod and a wide-angle lens. The best shots are taken from directly in front of the falls, slightly below the flame level. Use a slow shutter speed to blur the water while keeping the flame sharp. A polarizing filter helps reduce glare from wet rocks. If you plan to relight the flame, do it before setting up your camera, as the initial flare-up can be unpredictable.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the Eternal Flame always burning?
No. It is sometimes extinguished by heavy rainfall, flooding, or a temporary drop in gas pressure. Visitors often relight it with a lighter or match. It is not a permanent, self-sustaining flame.

Can I swim in the pool below the waterfall?
Swimming is not recommended. The pool is shallow and rocky, and the water is very cold. The rocks are slippery, and there is no lifeguard. Wading is possible but not advised.

How long is the hike?
From the Chestnut Ridge parking lot, the hike is about 0.6 miles one way, taking roughly 20-30 minutes. The return trip is uphill, so allow extra time.

Is the waterfall accessible for wheelchairs or strollers?
No. The trail is natural, uneven, and includes steep sections with exposed roots and rocks. It is not suitable for wheelchairs, strollers, or anyone with limited mobility.

Are there other waterfalls nearby?
Yes, within Chestnut Ridge Park there are a few smaller unnamed cascades along the same creek. Within a short drive, you can also visit Glen Falls in Williamsville and the larger Niagara Falls about 30 miles north.

Do I need a permit or reservation?
No permit is required. The park is open year-round from dawn to dusk, and the trail is free to use. There are no guided tours; you explore on your own.

Related

How pages are sourced and corrected: Sources and editorial policy.