OneStopList

Gods and goddesses

Which Position Should I Draft First? Fantasy Football

Updated November 18, 2026

Draft a running back with your first pick in virtually every standard fantasy football league. The combination of scarcity at the position, high weekly volume, and the steep drop-off after the top tier makes running back the highest-value first-round choice in most formats.

Why Running Backs Dominate the First Round

Fantasy football is a game of scarcity. You start at least two running backs in most leagues, but there are only about 15 to 20 running backs who are true three-down workhorses. Wide receivers are plentiful by comparison—dozens of pass-catchers see 100-plus targets each season. Because the gap between a top-five running back and a replacement-level starter is enormous, locking in an elite back early gives you a weekly advantage that is hard to replicate later.

Consider the numbers: in 2023, the top-scoring running back (Christian McCaffrey) outscored the RB12 by over 100 fantasy points in PPR leagues. Meanwhile, the WR1 (CeeDee Lamb) beat the WR12 by only about 50 points. That difference in positional drop-off is why running backs are drafted first in most competitive leagues.

How the First Round Has Changed

The NFL has shifted to more pass-heavy offenses and running-back committees, making elite bell-cow backs rarer than ever. A decade ago, a dozen running backs received 300-plus carries; today, only a handful do. This scarcity pushes the top backs even higher in drafts. However, the rise of elite young quarterbacks like Patrick Mahomes and Josh Allen has made some managers consider taking a quarterback early. But even the best quarterback rarely outscored the best running back by more than 60 points, and you can find a serviceable quarterback in round six or later.

The zero-RB strategy—deliberately avoiding running backs until the middle rounds—has gained popularity in recent years as a response to injuries and committee backfields. But that strategy works best in PPR leagues with three wide receiver spots and a flex, where you can load up on pass-catchers. In standard leagues, the running back advantage is too large to ignore.

League Settings Change the Answer

Your league’s scoring and roster rules should influence your first-round pick. Here are the key factors to weigh:

  • PPR (point per reception): In PPR, wide receivers gain value because they catch more passes. Still, elite pass-catching backs like McCaffrey or Bijan Robinson are even more valuable. A top back who catches 60 balls is a cheat code. If you pick late in the first round, a receiver like Justin Jefferson or Tyreek Hill is a fine pick, but an elite back should still be the priority.
  • Standard (non-PPR): Running backs are even more dominant in standard leagues because touchdowns and yardage matter more. A goal-line back who scores 15 touchdowns is gold. Draft a running back first here without hesitation.
  • Superflex (2 QBs): In superflex leagues, quarterbacks become the most valuable asset because you must start two. If you have a top-three pick, taking Patrick Mahomes or Josh Allen is justified. But in a normal 1-QB league, never take a quarterback in round one.
  • Number of starting spots: If you start three wide receivers and only two running backs, the receiver value rises. But most leagues still start two backs, so the running back premium remains.

How to Choose Between Running Backs

If you have the first overall pick, the choice is usually between a few elite backs. In 2024, Christian McCaffrey, Bijan Robinson, and Breece Hall were the consensus top three. When deciding among them, look at:

  • Volume: How many carries and targets does the player project to get? A back with 300 touches is safer than one with 200.
  • Offensive line and scheme: A back behind a top run-blocking line (like the Eagles or Browns) has a higher floor.
  • Injury history: Some backs have a track record of missing games. McCaffrey missed significant time in 2020 and 2021, but returned to play all 16 games in 2023.
  • Pass-catching role: In PPR, a back who catches 50 passes is worth more than one who catches 20.

Common First-Round Mistakes

Many managers overthink the first round. Here are the most frequent errors:

  • Taking a quarterback too early: In a 1-QB league, the difference between the QB1 and QB10 is about 5 points per game. The difference between RB1 and RB10 is often 10 points. Quarterback is deep—wait.
  • Drafting a tight end in round one: Travis Kelce was a first-round pick for years, but even he didn’t outscore the top running backs. Tight end is a shallow position, but you can find a serviceable one later.
  • Overvaluing rookies: Rookies like Bijan Robinson are exciting, but they come with uncertainty. A proven veteran like Derrick Henry might be safer.
  • Ignoring bye weeks: Don’t let a bye week dictate your first-round pick. Every player has one bye, and you can plan around it.

Alternative Strategies: Zero-RB and Hero-RB

If you’re in a PPR league with a late first-round pick, you might consider a modified approach:

  • Zero-RB: You draft wide receivers and maybe a tight end for the first five rounds, then load up on running backs with high upside in the middle rounds. This works if you are confident in finding sleeper backs like Rachaad White or James Conner late.
  • Hero-RB: You draft one elite running back in the first round, then wait until rounds 4-6 to draft your RB2. This balances safety and upside.

These strategies are viable, but they require a deep understanding of late-round targets. For most managers, drafting a running back first remains the simplest path to a playoff berth.

Costs and Risks of Drafting a Running Back First

The main risk is injury. Running backs get hurt more often than receivers because of the physical toll of the position. In 2023, J.K. Dobbins and Nick Chubb both suffered season-ending injuries early. That’s why you should always handcuff your top back—draft his backup later. For example, if you draft Breece Hall, consider picking up Israel Abanikanda as insurance. The cost is a late-round pick, but the payoff is a starting-caliber back if your star goes down.

Another risk is a committee backfield. Some teams use a rotation, which caps a back’s ceiling. Research the coaching staff’s tendencies before drafting. For instance, the 49ers have historically used a lead back, while the Patriots have used a committee.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I ever draft a wide receiver first?

Yes, if you pick late in the first round (say, 10th overall) and the top running backs are gone. In that case, taking a receiver like Justin Jefferson or Ja’Marr Chase is a solid choice. But if a top-five running back falls to you, take him.

What about drafting a quarterback like Patrick Mahomes first?

In a standard 1-QB league, no. Mahomes is great, but you can get a top-5 quarterback in round 5. The difference between Mahomes and, say, Dak Prescott is much smaller than the difference between a top running back and a replacement-level one.

Is the zero-RB strategy a good idea?

It can be, but only in PPR leagues with three starting wide receivers and a flex. In standard leagues, it’s risky because running backs score too many touchdowns. If you go zero-RB, you must be diligent in finding sleeper backs.

How do I know which running back to draft first?

Look at the player’s role, offensive line, and injury history. Use preseason rankings from reputable sites, but trust your own research. A back with a clear three-down role on a good offense is the safest pick.

What if I have the 1.01 pick in a superflex league?

In superflex, Patrick Mahomes or Josh Allen is the correct pick. Quarterbacks are the most valuable asset because you start two. But in any other format, take a running back.

Bottom Line

Draft a running back first in standard and PPR leagues. The position’s scarcity and weekly upside make it the most valuable asset in fantasy football. Adjust only if your league uses superflex rules or if you are picking at the end of the first round and all elite backs are gone. Otherwise, lock in a workhorse back and build your roster around him.

Related

How pages are sourced and corrected: Sources and editorial policy.